An irreverent Wall Street Blog
by Bill Singer

Merrill Lynch Hit With $8.5 Million Wrongful Termination Case

March 1, 2013

A picture taken on February 8, 2011 in Rennes,...

In a Financial Industry Regulatory Authority ("FINRA") Arbitration Statement of Claim filed in November 2011, and thereafter amended, Claimant Keating asserted wrongful termination, defamation, emotional distress, interference with business relations, and violation of Massachusetts Payment of Wages Law. Ultimately, Claimant sought $6 million in compensatory damages; $2.5 million in punitive damages, attorneys' fees, costs, and a recommendation of expungement. In the Matter of the FINRA Arbitration Between John Patrick, Keating, Claimant, vs. Merrill Lynch Pierce Fenner & Smith, Inc., Respondent (FINRA Arbitration 11-04254, February 26, 2013).

Respondent Merrill Lynch generally denied the allegations, asserted various affirmative defenses, and filed a Counterclaim for unjust enrichment and breach of promissory notes/refinance agreements. In its Counterclaim, in addition to attorneys' fees and costs, Merrill Lynch sought $135,657.07 in compensatory damages with 2.95% interest from July 28, 2011, until paid in full.

Stockbroker Fined And Suspended For Sending Business Emails From Personal AccountBill SingerBill SingerContributor
Broker Dealer President And Chief Compliance Officer Sued By FirmBill SingerBill SingerContributor

In response to Respondent's January 16, 2013,Motion In Limine and Claimant's opposition, the FINRA Hearing Panel precluded Claimant from "presenting medical related evidence In support of his emotional distress claim but could offer testimony and seek "garden variety" emotional distress damages."

The FINRA Arbitration Panel found:

  • Respondent Merrill Lynch liable and ordered the firm to pay to Claimant Keating $14,645.34 in compensatory damages  and $5,000 in attorneys' fees.
  • Claimant Keating liable and ordered him to pay to Respondent Merrill Lynch $135,657.07 in compensatory damages with $6,115.68 accrued 2.95% interest from July 28, 2011 until February 4, 2013; and $23,000 in attorneys' fees.
  • NOTE: The Panel offset the awards such that Claimant Keating owes Respondent Merrill Lynch $121,011.73 in compensatory damages and $18,000 in attorneys' fee
    s

Permalink

Search BrokeAndBroker

Related Topics

Previous Entries

Tag Cloud

Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker FINRA Arbitration AWC SEC BrokeAndBroker.com Expungement Employment Street Sweeper Bill SInger Jobs Wells Fargo OBA Fraud Promissory Note U5 Email U4 Merrill Lynch Wire Fraud UBS Elderly Forbes Morgan Stanley FBI EFL Guest Blog Statutory Disqualification PST CRD Defamation Suitability Citigroup ALJ Ponzi Guest Blogger Borrowing Rule 3270 Whistleblower BrokerCheck Supervision Outside Business Activity OIP IRS Bank Form U4 Wachovia Felony DOJ Willful Wrongful Termination BrokerAndBroker Aegis Frumento NAC Ameriprise Pro Se Mail Fraud Supreme Court SDNY IRA Expenses Discretion Rule 2080 CCO Insider Trading Wife WSP OHO Employment Tuesday Conversion Checks Husband Form U5 NASD Punitive Damages BrokeAndBroker Rule 8210 Madoff Dodd Frank Settlement Bankruptcy RIA Forgery Tax Raymond James Willfulness Estate Rule 3040 Frumento Discovery Credit Card Rule 3240 Private Securities Transaction Rule 1122 Power of Attorney Real Estate Commissions Rule 2010 Indictment JP Morgan Outside Business Activities Wall Street Business Expenses LPL NYSE Bank of America Bar Impersonation Street Legal Exam 2Cir Facebook Edward Jones ATM Rule 3280 Annuities Tax Lien Margin Mortgage Wire Complaint Antitrust Corrective Action Statement Case In Point Stephen Kohn Small Firm Spouse Offer of Settlement ETF Tax Liens Test Appeal SRO Rule 2510 Trust Schapiro Beneficiary Schwab Employee Forgivable Loan Misdemeanor VA ARS NSF Due Diligence Promissory Notes Goldman Sachs Trustee Injunction Securities Fraud Conspiracy NASAA CFTC HFT Away Account Unauthorized Discretion POA T&P Signatures Mandatory Arbitration Spouses Fidelity Initial Decision PCAOB Chase RBC Lien OTR Flash Crash Barclays Loan Signature Cease And Desist Annuity DCCir Deutsche Bank Compliance Rule 12206 Credit Cards Huffington Post Remand LOA Bonus Money Laundering Insurance Rule 4511 NASDAQ Great Recession Undisclosed Settlement MSSB email E*Trade Solicitation Failure to Supervise Rule 3010 Unfair Competition Hacker Liens Burris Rule 3050 Gallagher Eligibility Rule RRBDLAW.com Lehman Brothers Bharara Identity Theft Stay Continuing Education Registered Rep Magazine Options Variable Annuity Scottrade Annual Compliance Questionnaire Fiduciary Letter of Authorization JPMorgan Reimbursement Malware Hacking Stockbrokers Disclosure Apple employment FINRA Arbitration Wedbush Forex Audit Retirement Customer brokeandbroker 2nd Circuit Registration OWB Away Accounts arbitration Variable Annuities Second Circuit Website Rule 12805 Dissent Prison Solicited Sexist Broker Protocol Deceased Net Capital Customer Complaint Divorce TRO jobs Unsuitability BrokeAndBroker Bill Singer LIBOR Social Media Will Motion to Dismiss Wey FINOP Rule 4530 Unsolicited Trump Reg SP 10Cir Brummer Sexism Zipper Unauthorized Trading ACQ RMBS BOP Internet Plea Judgments BrokeandBroker BrokeAndBroker.com Blog Telephone Private Placement Hilton Weiner China Time And Price Willfully FOREX Sanctions Commission Private Securities Transactions Bureau of Prisons Arbitraiton RRBDlaw.com IC3 Newman MetLife Trading Platform Personal Expenses Lehman FNMA Rule 2150 Statute of Limitations Stifel Nicolaus Hedge Fund Piwowar Knight Disgorgement DOL ADA NYAG Testimony Securities Industry Commentator IPO Stifel Confidential Information Self Regulation Unjust Enrichment Auction Rate Securities Rule 12200 Rakoff Crowdfunding WSPs Cheating REIT Joshua Brown Dakota Securities Explained Decision Obstruction of Justice Check Kiting Protocol Examination MC-400 Spoofing Postponement Marijuana Discrimination Rule 2111 Emails bill singer Indemnification Lucia Morgan Keegan Khuzami Churning Reg D Affiliate Class Action Aleynikov SAC Medicare Raiding OIG 9Cir Affinity Fraud Charles Schwab Rule 3110 OSHA Botkin Sanction Guidelines Rule 2081 Bonds Fees Vacatur Phishing Board Mutual Funds Jurisdiction Appointments Clause Regulation SP Executor Passcode Confidential CEO PN Compensation PNC Morgan Stanely Woody Allen Debit Card Hurry Retaliation High Frequency Trading Wine Stanford Article V Rule 13805 MF Global Waiver Bloomberg JOBS Act Imposter Wire Transfer Bandimere EIA Lawyer Ketchum Gold Charge Conflict Banc of America Shah Gilani Rosenthal Recruiting Pennystock Oppenheimer Due Process Check Blockchain Elder Abuse Rule 3030 Disability Marine Corps HSBC Consent Order Bear Stearns Hearing Testing CE Unregistered Deferred Compensation Private Placements Reg S-P Loans Pennystocks Severance Ride the Thunder TD Ameritrade Confirm Crypto Mother Mutual Fund TSSB Dementia Vietnam Outside Account Marines Series 7 Written Supervisory Procedures Smith Barney Aguilar Rule 9552 Online Concentration Side Bar ING Rule 4513 McDuff Johnny Burris White Trade Secrets Yesenia Guitron Self Regulatory Organization Eligibility Sales Assistant Charity Whistleblowing Widow SunTrust 6th Circuit USERRA Bank Fraud Commodities Fraud Embezzlement Vault Government Accountability Project Statutory Disqualification Committee Chief Compliance Officer Casino Margin Call Corruption Small Firm Governor Parking Corzine Bid Rigging Termination TOD Laptop AML NPR Whitman Marketplace Membership Continuance Failure To Supervise Information Teleconference Customer Information Restaurant Puerto Rico Guitron Penson PAQ Poteroba Day Trading 401k Finder\'s Fee Suspension Cannabis Employment Agreement Accounting Morgan Stanley Smith Barney Statement of Corrective Action Kon Regulation Motion to Vacate Credit Suisse Florida David Sobel BrokeAndbroker Unauthorized Practice of Law 40 Act Argentina Investor Alert CGMI Moon Inability to Pay Jennifer Tarr Female Broke And Broker Rule 12504 Cold Spring Advisory Group Thain Standing Password Non-Solicitation Public Interest Commodities Congress Elles Department of Justice Constitution Non Solicitation Circuit Court Money Market TIC OCIE Stop Loss BATS Tortious Interference Electronic Communications Rule 9216 Chase Investment Services Arrest CPA Rory Flynn Unsuitable Fifth Amendment Reverse Life Insurance Rule 2210 Fowler Negligence Schneiderman Probate signature Verbal Discretion Taft Correctional Institution Inside Information Christian Stanley 11th Circuit Chiasson FCI Beaumont FCI Motion Timban OWWP Rule 13200 Sexual Harassment Wanger Research RRBDlaw Settling Away Oral Discretion CNBC WaMu BD Stipulated Award ACH Leveraged ETF 9/11 Over Concentration Withdrawals CRS Outside Accounts Elder Law expungement FINRA AWC Investment Adviser Third Party Vendor Stockbroker David Lerner Do Not Call 401(k) Lincoln Financial Manifest Disregard Counterclaim Commissioner Stein Judgment Escrow Netschi Hospital Subpoena Joint Account Client Information Feigenbaum 4Cir Cryptocurrency Layering Counterfeit Rule 1031 Moore Inmate Form ADV Turnover Equity Indexed Annuities Nietzsche SP Backstage Wall Street Tax Fraud TheBlot Medical Condition Sharemaster IAR Scholander Star Wars BrokerAndBroker.com VXX Rule 2370 Federal Reserve Sexual Discrimination Robert Cook FOCUS Kiting Red Flags Guest Bloggers Board of Governors Scottsdale Fine Obstruction Administrative Remedies Dell Summary Judgment Kent Death National Securities TCR Bank Guarantee Galleon Capital Gains Regulation S-P Reason for Termination Customer Files Stephen A. Kohn IM Blank Forms Kenneth Starr Proctor Expert Witness Reuters Nationwide Resignation S&P Motion To Dismiss Promoter Fourth Amendment ADR AXA Brokeandbroker.com Oilpro Gabelli Mary Jo White Falsification Murray Trader Molchatsky God Puts Retired Woman With Cane Undertaking 8210 Chevron Pruco Coin Lek Stock Promotion Sears Skimming Branch Manager iPhone Supervisor Dinner Eric Stein Wire Transfers CD Short Sale Compromise Wires Annual Audit Elon Musk Initials Taxes Outside Counsel Test Center Reverse Merger Excessive Trading CDO In House Counsel 1Cir Scam Merger Compliance Questionnaire 17a-5 GAP Financial Disclosure Johnson Cellphone Disparate Treatment First Amendment JPM US Airways Women Advisor Placement Group Liquidation Obamacare Preet Bharara Salman Service BrokeAndBroke Fiero DWI Texting BitTorrent Fines Springsteen McCartney Practice Sale Texas State Securities Board Mistake Tennis Court Flash Drive BBVA Expense SD Bill singer Wages MSPB FMLA MBS FINRA Board Goble Collateral Bar Municipal Advisor Turbeville Broy Nasdaq NRSRO Conflicts Retroactive Bar Retroactive Newbridge Statute of Limitation Checking Rule 12212 FNI Media FDA Jon Corzine House Financial Services NYG Capital Impersonator Undercover Office of Special Counsel Martoma Janney Montgomery Scott SIFMA Father Newport Coast Securities Google SEC Rules of Practice Anderson Evidence Attorneys\' Fees Merrill Sex Trading State Farm Credit Repair Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker NFA Cherry Picking Willfull Bartko Kierkegaard BIll Singer Exhaustion Doctrine Silver Lee Securities and Exchange Commission Mattera Merill Lynch RRBDLAW FAA Laser Reform Data 9th Circuit Trainee Fee Currency FCPA Theft Non-Prosecution Agreement Pacifico NML LLC Subway Kennedy Prime Bank Relevant Grievance Martin Compliance Officer Diabetes Dow Rule 420 AAA VIX Solomon Customers Schumer Finra Spoliation Immunity Attorneys Fees 1099 BrokeandBroker.com FTC Spam Work Product Leveraged ETFs Collateral Rule 3210 Koval Costa Rica Rule 2330 Cybercrime Apartment Pension Excel Privilege Selling Away Walter Books And Records AIG Chase Bank Fiduciary Duty Criminal Fee Payroll Travel AWC. FINRA Hugh Hewitt WB-APP Amazon Rule 21F Bitcoin Rules of Practice Offset Boyland Witness Tampering Funds Hertz Microcap Mary Schapiro FINRA Small Firm Risk SIPC Slander Disciplinary History Lawyers Quasi Governmental PIABA Tran Elder Fraud Bribe Countrywide Lewis Carroll Varney Enforcement Baby Boomers Sarbanes Oxley Tippee EDNY Motion to Compel Permanent Bar CMO Personal Information Sharing Agreement Tipper Ethics Naskovets Wells Fargo Advisors false statements Executrix Books and Records Meals Altered Records Transfer Constructive Discharge