An irreverent Wall Street Blog
by Bill Singer

David Lerner And Apple REITs Defendants In Stunning Class Action Victory

April 5, 2013

In a dramatic Eastern District of New York Opinion by Judge Matsumoto, the Apple REITs class action Defendants' Motion to Dismiss was granted. David Lerner Associates and the Apple REITs emerge victorious in this contentious and high-profile class action. 

Read the Memorandum and Order. In Re Apple REITs Litigation (EDNY,11-CV-2919, April 4, 2013). As the Court noted on page 44 of its Opinion:

Here, however, Plaintiffs have failed to proffer an actionable theory of loss.

In sum, Plaintiffs' belabored Complaint appears only to confirm that the Apple REITs are currently functioning in exactly the manner that was anticipated and disclosed in the REITs' prospectuses and other offering documents. . .

In similarly stark and dismissive language, the Court states on page 47 of its Opinion:

As the court previously discussed, Plaintiffs have failed to sufficiently plead any damages as a result of Defendants' purported misrepresentations or omissions with respect to the Apple REITs. To the contrary, the Complaint alleges that Plaintiffs have in fact consistently earned money from the Apple REITs. (See Compl. ¶ 183 (discussing the REITs' "consistent 7-8% distributions").) Accordingly, Plaintiffs' claim for common law breach of fiduciary duty must be and is dismissed.

Permalink

Search BrokeAndBroker

Related Topics

Previous Entries

Tag Cloud

Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker FINRA Arbitration AWC SEC BrokeAndBroker.com Expungement Employment Street Sweeper Bill SInger Jobs Wells Fargo Fraud U5 OBA Promissory Note Guest Blog U4 Email Guest Blogger BrokerAndBroker Aegis Frumento Merrill Lynch Wire Fraud EFL Morgan Stanley Elderly UBS CRD Forbes Defamation FBI PST Statutory Disqualification Suitability Ponzi ALJ Citigroup Rule 3270 Whistleblower Borrowing DOJ Supervision BrokerCheck Outside Business Activity Bank IRS OIP Willful BrokeAndBroker Felony Form U4 NAC SDNY Expenses Wrongful Termination Wachovia Pro Se OHO Ameriprise Supreme Court IRA Rule 2080 Mail Fraud Insider Trading Wife WSP Husband Discretion Rule 8210 Dodd Frank Checks Forgery Conversion CCO RIA Rule 1122 Form U5 Employment Tuesday Bankruptcy Tax Punitive Damages Raymond James Business Expenses NASD Discovery Settlement InSecurities Madoff Rule 3240 Estate Willfulness Rule 3040 Rule 2010 Private Securities Transaction JP Morgan Frumento Wall Street Credit Card NYSE Small Firm LPL Indictment Real Estate Power of Attorney Annuities Outside Business Activities Commissions 2Cir Bar Promissory Notes Facebook Impersonation Rule 3280 Edward Jones Exam Corrective Action Statement ETF Margin Bank of America Securities Industry Commentator Tax Liens Spouse Tax Lien Street Legal SRO Mortgage Beneficiary ATM Offer of Settlement Injunction Complaint Schwab Case In Point Test Stephen Kohn Trust Antitrust Wire Rule 2510 Signature Options ARS Schapiro Away Account Rule 12206 Trump Appeal Insurance Annuity CFTC T&P VA Trustee Loan Spouses Misdemeanor Employee Forgivable Loan NSF Barclays Initial Decision POA Due Diligence Goldman Sachs Unauthorized Discretion Remand Securities Fraud Deutsche Bank Signatures RBC OTR Lien Conspiracy HFT NASAA Liens Crypto Blockchain Sanctions NASDAQ PCAOB Flash Crash Money Laundering Cease And Desist Eligibility Rule Fidelity Mandatory Arbitration DCCir Bonus Great Recession Chase Credit Cards E*Trade Rule 4530 Huffington Post Continuing Education email Compliance Stay Undisclosed Settlement Burris Failure to Supervise Dissent LOA Rule 4511 TRO Rule 3010 Deceased Unsuitability Disclosure Scottrade Solicitation OWB Rule 3050 Registered Rep Magazine Bharara Identity Theft Customer MSSB Unfair Competition Broker Protocol ACQ Willfully Lehman Brothers Hacker Fiduciary RRBDLAW.com Gallagher Hacking Variable Annuity Divorce Cryptocurrency FINRA Arbitration Stockbrokers Wedbush Spoofing Website Explained Decision arbitration Reimbursement Discrimination Jurisdiction JPMorgan Malware Annual Compliance Questionnaire Bitcoin Unauthorized Trading Board Audit Motion to Dismiss Reg SP employment Forex Retirement Sexist brokeandbroker Apple Letter of Authorization Severance Social Media Away Accounts Retaliation FINOP Registration Will 2nd Circuit Rule 12200 Personal Expenses jobs Second Circuit Prison Solicited RMBS Sexism Lucia LIBOR Net Capital Rule 12805 Self Regulation Lehman Elder Abuse BrokeAndBroker Bill Singer Variable Annuities Customer Complaint Wey Disgorgement Vacatur Internet Stifel Examination REIT FOREX Hilton Weiner Unsolicited Private Placement Commission 9Cir Charles Schwab 10Cir MetLife Trading Platform Brummer Plea Arbitraiton Indemnification Time And Price RRBDlaw.com Zipper BrokeAndBroker.com Blog BrokeandBroker Bureau of Prisons Postponement Loans Imposter Waiver China Hedge Fund Bonds Marijuana IC3 Motion to Vacate Judgments BOP Confidential Information Newman Telephone Private Securities Transactions Joshua Brown TD Ameritrade WSPs Check Kiting Emails MC-400 OSHA FAA bill singer Auction Rate Securities Dakota Securities Botkin CNBC NYAG Piwowar Rakoff Unjust Enrichment Obstruction of Justice Fees Compensation Widow Knight Mutual Funds Cheating Statute of Limitations Lawyer PNC Rule 2150 Debit Card FNMA DOL Rule 2111 IPO Stifel Nicolaus Sanction Guidelines Protocol Testimony Crowdfunding ADA JOBS Act Suspension CE Coronavirus CPA Morgan Keegan Rule 3110 TOD Sales Assistant Bandimere Charge Inability to Pay Appointments Clause ING Board of Governors Employment Agreement Rosenthal Recruiting Cannabis Aleynikov Credit Suisse Khuzami AML Counterclaim CRS Oppenheimer Unsuitable Rule 9552 Non Solicitation Rule 2081 Woody Allen SAC Wine EIA Due Process Check Banc of America Public Interest Rule 13200 Reg S-P Reg D Affinity Fraud CEO Manifest Disregard Dementia Affiliate Class Action Shah Gilani Whistleblowing Executor Rule 13805 Regulation SP Series 7 Wire Transfer Embezzlement Raiding Customer Information Bear Stearns Confirm Bloomberg PN Confidential Medicare Passcode Gold Stanford Elder Fraud Restaurant Phishing Conflict Rule 12504 Article V MF Global Hurry Churning Ketchum Pennystock Morgan Stanely TSSB High Frequency Trading USERRA OIG Puerto Rico Parking Statutory Disqualification Committee ICO Bank Fraud Nietzsche Moon IM Finder\'s Fee Slander Written Supervisory Procedures PAQ Membership Continuance Deferred Compensation Broke And Broker Corzine Mother Standing Joint Account Small Firm Governor Commodities Fraud Casino Unauthorized Practice of Law Probate ACH Chief Compliance Officer Smith Barney Charity Penson Feigenbaum Margin Call Morgan Stanley Smith Barney HSBC Self Regulatory Organization Amazon Marine Corps Marines Vault Ride the Thunder Vietnam White Private Placements Johnny Burris Obstruction Eligibility Guitron Yesenia Guitron McDuff Whitman Government Accountability Project expungement TCR Leveraged ETF Rule 3030 Accounting Testing Information Rule 4513 Rule 2210 Bid Rigging Unregistered Statement of Corrective Action 6th Circuit Kokesh Corruption SunTrust Mutual Fund Linde Murphy Outside Account Disability Hearing Teleconference 401k Termination Marketplace Kon Poteroba Form ADV Star Wars Concentration Pennystocks NPR David Sobel WB-APP Layering Consent Order Failure To Supervise Medical Condition Laptop Subpoena Circuit Court Tortious Interference Motion to Confirm Day Trading Trade Secrets Funds Online Side Bar Federal Reserve Aguilar TheBlot Regulation Resignation Inside Information Settling Away Netschi Libel Lincoln Financial Texting Puts Elder Law Counterfeit CDO Turnover Fifth Amendment Scholander Guest Bloggers Over Concentration First Amendment Death BrokeAndbroker SIFMA Withdrawals WaMu SP RICO Outside Accounts Control Person Test Center Selling Away Money Market PIABA Kiting Thain Third Party Vendor signature Rule 21F Password Moore FINRA AWC Constitution Scottsdale Research Rule 9216 Chiasson 11th Circuit Respondeat Superior Congress Excessive Trading Fowler David Lerner 9/11 ESOP OWWP Client Information IAR Sexual Harassment Electronic Communications Negligence RRBDlaw Verbal Discretion 1Cir Schneiderman Rule 12904 Oral Discretion Stockbroker Investment Adviser EDNY Commissioner Stein Backstage Wall Street 401(k) Do Not Call Commodities Equity Indexed Annuities FOCUS Motion Hester Peirce Timban Hospital BrokerAndBroker.com Wanger Sarbanes Oxley Non-Solicitation 40 Act YouTube CD Robert Cook Red Flags Tax Fraud JPM BATS Fiduciary Duty OCIE Argentina FCI Ethereum Stipulated Award Department of Justice Rule 1031 Florida Reverse Life Insurance Administrative Remedies Rule 12212 Inmate Female FCI Beaumont Sexual Discrimination Chase Investment Services Judgment Stop Loss Arrest Jennifer Tarr Elles Google Privilege Investor Alert Arbitration Dell Cold Spring Advisory Group BrokeAndBroke Escrow Fine Fines Rule 2370 Attorneys\' Fees Sharemaster Taft Correctional Institution Robert Muh 4Cir VIX CGMI Christian Stanley Meals AXA Talman Harris Data Trading 11Cir VXX TIC BD Attorneys Fees Rory Flynn Clayton Turbeville Non Solicit Scam Lexicon Currency Prime Bank MSPB Game of Thrones FDA GAP God Customer Files Merill Lynch FINRA Board Blank Forms Reverse Merger Subway Capitalism Covid-19 Undertaking Lek QuadrigaCX Springsteen McCartney Women 6Cir Romer Guardian FCPA Mattera Obamacare Series 79 Disparate Treatment Reuters Laser Flash Drive Nasdaq SD Johnson Expense Kennedy Cellphone US Airways Preet Bharara LLC Initials Taxes Non-Prosecution Agreement 8210 Trainee Fee Cherry Picking Molchatsky Sears Conflicts Newbridge Wages Service Confidential Customer Information Bill singer Grievance Beneficiaries Anderson Practice Sale Martin Bank Guarantee Regulation S-P Kent Cryptocurrencies Mary Jo White Janney Montgomery Scott National Securities MBS Martoma Promoter Oilpro Jon Corzine Advisor Placement Group Merrill Office of Special Counsel Exhaustion Doctrine Eric Stein Trader Unauthorized Trades Fiero State Farm Father Merger Credit Repair DWI Section 206 Exception Reports Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker UIT Bezos Proctor Series 66 BIll Singer ADR Gabelli Fourth Amendment Elon Musk Silver NoCA Impersonator Restitution Goble Production Diamonds Pacifico NML Life Insurance Berthel Fisher BitTorrent Texas State Securities Board Summary Judgment Motion To Dismiss Checking Undercover Lee BBVA Compliance Officer SEC Rules of Practice Branch Manager Copyright Theft Well Managed Portfolio Evidence Willfull S&P Life Settlement Capital Gains Short Sale Collateral Bar William Faulkner Retroactive Bar Retroactive Municipal Advisor Enforcement Fee NRSRO Apartment Countrywide IBM Tran Stephen A. Kohn Altered Records NYG Capital BrokeandBroker.com Mary Schapiro Spoliation Criminal Gifts Bartko Mistake Boyland Retired Woman With Cane Disciplinary History NFA Tennis Court Deferred Prosecution Agreement Lewis Carroll false statements Newport Coast Securities Kierkegaard Pension Transfer Executrix Confirmation Constructive Discharge Books And Records Bribe Witness Tampering Excel Brokeandbroker.com Securities and Exchange Commission FNI Media Reasonable Dow Rule 3310 Reform Schumer Statute of Limitation State Actor Quasi Governmental Solomon Diabetes Self Directed Financial Disclosure Banks Bob Dylan Prudential Lawyers Ethics Powell Risk Spam ALJ Grimes Walter Fraudulent Inducement Compliance Questionnaire Expert Witness Collateral Arbitrator EDPA Work Product Leveraged ETFs Exotic ETF Tipper Tippee SDFL Rule 2330 Baby Boomers Immunity Sterne Agee Rule 420 1099 CMO Self Reporting Books and Records Finra FMLA AAA SIPC Koval Cybercrime Outside Counsel Hertz FINRA Small Firm 3Cir Rules of Practice AWC. FINRA Murray Annual Audit Hugh Hewitt Falsification 17a-5 Municipal Bonds Kenneth Starr In House Counsel NY Life Customers Age Discrimination ADEA Reason for Termination Offset Sex Skimming AIG Naskovets Motion to Compel Salman Irreparable Harm Varney Galleon Stock Promotion Liquidation Coin 10b-5 Whistleblowers Binary Options Crime Supervisor Costa Rica JPMorgan Chase PHC Permanent Bar iPhone Compromise Wires Chevron Travel 9th Circuit Wells Fargo Advisors Election Sharing Agreement RRBDLAW DPA Rule 9554 FTC Dinner Pruco Microcap Wire Transfers Nationwide Broy Payroll Rule 3210 Personal Information Honorarium Relevant Saad Chase Bank Orders Daspin House Financial Services