An irreverent Wall Street Blog
by Bill Singer

David Lerner And Apple REITs Defendants In Stunning Class Action Victory

April 5, 2013

In a dramatic Eastern District of New York Opinion by Judge Matsumoto, the Apple REITs class action Defendants' Motion to Dismiss was granted. David Lerner Associates and the Apple REITs emerge victorious in this contentious and high-profile class action. 

Read the Memorandum and Order. In Re Apple REITs Litigation (EDNY,11-CV-2919, April 4, 2013). As the Court noted on page 44 of its Opinion:

Here, however, Plaintiffs have failed to proffer an actionable theory of loss.

In sum, Plaintiffs' belabored Complaint appears only to confirm that the Apple REITs are currently functioning in exactly the manner that was anticipated and disclosed in the REITs' prospectuses and other offering documents. . .

In similarly stark and dismissive language, the Court states on page 47 of its Opinion:

As the court previously discussed, Plaintiffs have failed to sufficiently plead any damages as a result of Defendants' purported misrepresentations or omissions with respect to the Apple REITs. To the contrary, the Complaint alleges that Plaintiffs have in fact consistently earned money from the Apple REITs. (See Compl. ¶ 183 (discussing the REITs' "consistent 7-8% distributions").) Accordingly, Plaintiffs' claim for common law breach of fiduciary duty must be and is dismissed.

Permalink

Search BrokeAndBroker

Related Topics

Previous Entries

Tag Cloud

Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker FINRA Arbitration AWC SEC BrokeAndBroker.com Expungement Employment Street Sweeper Jobs Bill SInger Wells Fargo Fraud OBA U5 Promissory Note Email U4 Wire Fraud UBS Forbes Merrill Lynch Elderly FBI Morgan Stanley Statutory Disqualification EFL PST Citigroup ALJ Suitability Defamation CRD Borrowing Ponzi Rule 3270 BrokerCheck Outside Business Activity OIP Whistleblower IRS Supervision Guest Blog Form U4 Wachovia Felony Bank Willful DOJ Wrongful Termination SDNY Mail Fraud Supreme Court NAC Expenses BrokerAndBroker Guest Blogger Ameriprise CCO Discretion Pro Se Insider Trading Checks Form U5 IRA Employment Tuesday Madoff Conversion Rule 2080 OHO Raymond James Wife Bankruptcy WSP Punitive Damages Credit Card Rule 3040 Husband Willfulness Forgery NASD Rule 3240 Private Securities Transaction Estate Dodd Frank Discovery Tax Settlement Rule 2010 Rule 8210 Rule 1122 RIA Outside Business Activities Real Estate JP Morgan Indictment Business Expenses Frumento Exam Street Legal LPL Power of Attorney 2Cir Commissions Wall Street Impersonation Facebook Bar Annuities NYSE Tax Lien Edward Jones ATM Case In Point Antitrust Margin Mortgage BrokeAndBroker Stephen Kohn Corrective Action Statement Rule 3280 Small Firm Bank of America SRO Test Appeal Spouse Tax Liens Wire Schapiro Due Diligence Rule 2510 ARS Offer of Settlement Beneficiary Misdemeanor Complaint Employee Forgivable Loan Goldman Sachs Schwab Trust NSF Trustee HFT Aegis Frumento NASAA Securities Fraud Signatures ETF T&P Promissory Notes VA Conspiracy Loan Annuity Signature RBC Chase PCAOB Cease And Desist Flash Crash Lien Fidelity Injunction Initial Decision Mandatory Arbitration Away Account Deutsche Bank NASDAQ POA Barclays DCCir Money Laundering Credit Cards LOA CFTC Unauthorized Discretion Spouses Huffington Post Bonus Gallagher Scottrade Lehman Brothers OTR Unfair Competition Bharara Remand Failure to Supervise Identity Theft Liens Hacker Great Recession email Burris Insurance MSSB Undisclosed Settlement Compliance RRBDLAW.com Stay Variable Annuity Registered Rep Magazine Continuing Education Stockbrokers FINRA Arbitration E*Trade Rule 12206 Wedbush JPMorgan employment Malware Audit Disclosure Solicitation Options Fiduciary Rule 3010 Annual Compliance Questionnaire Letter of Authorization Eligibility Rule Forex Wey Retirement arbitration LIBOR Second Circuit FINOP brokeandbroker Rule 12805 Registration Rule 4511 Prison Rule 3050 Hacking Social Media Website BrokeAndBroker Bill Singer Customer Complaint Will Net Capital 2nd Circuit Solicited Reimbursement Customer jobs TRO Away Accounts Motion to Dismiss Brummer Bureau of Prisons Private Placement Time And Price FOREX Unsolicited Newman Personal Expenses Variable Annuities Trading Platform China Willfully Judgments Private Securities Transactions Rule 4530 Sanctions 10Cir Reg SP Internet Lehman Unsuitability Dissent Plea IC3 BrokeandBroker BOP OWB RRBDlaw.com Broker Protocol Telephone Zipper Unauthorized Trading Apple RMBS Lucia REIT Divorce Auction Rate Securities Spoofing Confidential Information Check Kiting NYAG Stifel Stifel Nicolaus Obstruction of Justice Crowdfunding Cheating Explained Decision ADA Self Regulation Deceased Examination Piwowar MC-400 FNMA Rule 12200 BrokeAndBroker.com Blog Disgorgement DOL Dakota Securities MetLife Hedge Fund Knight Arbitraiton Commission Rakoff Rule 2111 WSPs Statute of Limitations Protocol Ketchum PN Jurisdiction Emails Reg D Wire Transfer Waiver SAC Debit Card Hilton Weiner Executor bill singer Vacatur Hurry Bonds Charge Wine Churning Stanford MF Global Phishing ACQ Woody Allen Confidential Bandimere EIA Postponement Khuzami JOBS Act Sexist Class Action Compensation Aleynikov High Frequency Trading Article V Morgan Keegan Affinity Fraud Marijuana Due Process Passcode Indemnification Joshua Brown Discrimination Gold Rosenthal Recruiting Check Shah Gilani Lawyer Appointments Clause Raiding Banc of America Pennystock Regulation SP Board Sanction Guidelines Rule 2081 OIG Medicare Conflict Rule 2150 Affiliate 9Cir Botkin OSHA Fees PNC IPO Retaliation Failure To Supervise SunTrust Small Firm Governor 401k White Written Supervisory Procedures Information AML Charles Schwab Bloomberg Sales Assistant Mutual Fund Penson Membership Continuance Self Regulatory Organization Corruption Testing Chief Compliance Officer Private Placements Vault CE ING Rule 3110 Laptop Side Bar TD Ameritrade Online Puerto Rico Unregistered Bid Rigging Embezzlement Kon Reg S-P Morgan Stanley Smith Barney Statement of Corrective Action McDuff Charity Confirm Teleconference CEO Dementia HSBC Bank Fraud Elder Abuse Smith Barney Oppenheimer Finder\'s Fee Bear Stearns Marines Disability Pennystocks Accounting Employment Agreement Morgan Stanely Consent Order Whistleblowing Securities Industry Commentator Loans Rule 3030 NPR Sexism Restaurant Ride the Thunder USERRA Day Trading Mutual Funds Eligibility Widow Yesenia Guitron Whitman Government Accountability Project Guitron Deferred Compensation Corzine Johnny Burris Parking Rule 13805 Commodities Fraud Series 7 Marketplace Unjust Enrichment 6th Circuit Imposter Testimony Customer Information Suspension Termination Poteroba Casino Statutory Disqualification Committee Hearing Aguilar Marine Corps Vietnam Concentration Thain Moon Chase Investment Services RRBDlaw Timban CGMI Arrest Rule 2210 Motion Outside Accounts Sexual Harassment Fowler Over Concentration Password FOCUS Client Information Circuit Court IAR Department of Justice Margin Call Commodities Star Wars BATS Congress signature Form ADV Probate Fifth Amendment Elles Do Not Call Inside Information Settling Away WaMu Inmate Medical Condition Non-Solicitation TOD Stop Loss Wanger 40 Act Chiasson Research Outside Account Counterclaim TSSB SP David Sobel Rule 1031 11th Circuit OWWP FCI Counterfeit 401(k) PAQ Commissioner Stein Lincoln Financial TheBlot Kiting Equity Indexed Annuities Third Party Vendor FCI Beaumont Judgment Stipulated Award CNBC Broke And Broker Backstage Wall Street BrokerAndBroker.com Hospital Negligence Layering Withdrawals Red Flags Verbal Discretion Fine Argentina Guest Bloggers Robert Cook Oral Discretion Taft Correctional Institution FINRA AWC Reverse Life Insurance Cannabis Investor Alert Schneiderman Rule 2370 Christian Stanley Investment Adviser Stockbroker Dell Mother Joint Account expungement Scholander CRS Unsuitable Constitution Netschi Moore 4Cir Escrow Female Board of Governors Leveraged ETF TIC Motion to Vacate Rule 9216 Unauthorized Practice of Law Tax Fraud OCIE CPA Feigenbaum Sharemaster Federal Reserve Scottsdale Administrative Remedies Inability to Pay Tortious Interference Credit Suisse Florida BD Public Interest Severance Trade Secrets ACH Standing Currency Johnson Puts Test Center 1Cir Rory Flynn Taxes Undertaking CMO Initials Merill Lynch JPM Cellphone US Airways Personal Information Annual Audit Meals Lek MSPB Constructive Discharge Chevron Stephen A. Kohn Excessive Trading 17a-5 Kent Financial Disclosure Oilpro Reverse Merger Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker Cherry Picking Falsification Elder Fraud Trader Proctor AXA Retired Woman With Cane Newbridge Gabelli Sharing Agreement TCR Varney Exhaustion Doctrine In House Counsel Non-Prosecution Agreement Books and Records Tennis Court Outside Counsel Fourth Amendment Relevant Obstruction Reuters Blank Forms Summary Judgment false statements Pacifico Customer Files Permanent Bar Money Market Office of Special Counsel AAA NRSRO Lee Municipal Advisor MBS Bartko CD Mary Jo White Compliance Questionnaire FDA Collateral Bar Retroactive Bar NYG Capital FNI Media Impersonator Compliance Officer Goble Retroactive FINRA Board Anderson Attorneys\' Fees Merrill Theft Wells Fargo Advisors Supervisor ADR EDNY iPhone Flash Drive Turbeville Dinner Death Conflicts Nasdaq Expense Wire Transfers Fiero Fines Regulation S-P DWI BrokeAndBroke Short Sale Willfull Wires Compromise GAP BitTorrent Jon Corzine CDO Liquidation S&P BBVA Pruco Promoter Service LLC Motion To Dismiss Bill singer Salman Disparate Treatment Merger Apartment Branch Manager Eric Stein David Lerner Pension God Molchatsky Disciplinary History Sears AWC. FINRA Resignation Preet Bharara SD BrokeAndbroker Texas State Securities Board Advisor Placement Group Subpoena Checking Grievance Rule 4513 Texting Rule 13200 Credit Repair Prime Bank FMLA Subway Hugh Hewitt FCPA FINRA Small Firm Martin Stock Promotion Bank Guarantee Scam 8210 BrokeandBroker.com Manifest Disregard Nietzsche Rule 9552 Springsteen BIll Singer PIABA Reason for Termination Rules of Practice Solomon Excel Lewis Carroll Mary Schapiro Father Risk Attorneys Fees Quasi Governmental House Financial Services Rule 420 Securities and Exchange Commission Undercover Broy Bribe Enforcement Janney Montgomery Scott Galleon Fiduciary Duty McCartney Turnover Martoma SIPC Criminal Silver Baby Boomers VXX 9th Circuit Funds Diabetes Dow Data Rule 12504 Practice Sale NFA Brokeandbroker.com Ethics Spam Mistake Lawyers Statute of Limitation Schumer Non Solicitation Countrywide Regulation Spoliation Nationwide RRBDLAW Tran Customers Trading Sexual Discrimination Mattera Walter 1099 Sex Executrix Privilege NML Kennedy Tippee Kenneth Starr FTC Electronic Communications Newport Coast Securities Koval Boyland Fee Murray Leveraged ETFs Collateral Jennifer Tarr Google State Farm Skimming Elder Law Naskovets Hertz Cold Spring Advisory Group Finra Books And Records Immunity Reform Laser Costa Rica Selling Away Tipper Evidence SEC Rules of Practice Travel Altered Records Payroll SIFMA Trainee Fee Cybercrime Wages Chase Bank AIG 9/11 Expert Witness Obamacare