An irreverent Wall Street Blog
by Bill Singer

David Lerner And Apple REITs Defendants In Stunning Class Action Victory

April 5, 2013

In a dramatic Eastern District of New York Opinion by Judge Matsumoto, the Apple REITs class action Defendants' Motion to Dismiss was granted. David Lerner Associates and the Apple REITs emerge victorious in this contentious and high-profile class action. 

Read the Memorandum and Order. In Re Apple REITs Litigation (EDNY,11-CV-2919, April 4, 2013). As the Court noted on page 44 of its Opinion:

Here, however, Plaintiffs have failed to proffer an actionable theory of loss.

In sum, Plaintiffs' belabored Complaint appears only to confirm that the Apple REITs are currently functioning in exactly the manner that was anticipated and disclosed in the REITs' prospectuses and other offering documents. . .

In similarly stark and dismissive language, the Court states on page 47 of its Opinion:

As the court previously discussed, Plaintiffs have failed to sufficiently plead any damages as a result of Defendants' purported misrepresentations or omissions with respect to the Apple REITs. To the contrary, the Complaint alleges that Plaintiffs have in fact consistently earned money from the Apple REITs. (See Compl. ¶ 183 (discussing the REITs' "consistent 7-8% distributions").) Accordingly, Plaintiffs' claim for common law breach of fiduciary duty must be and is dismissed.

Permalink

Search BrokeAndBroker

Related Topics

Previous Entries

Tag Cloud

Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker FINRA Arbitration AWC SEC BrokeAndBroker.com Expungement Employment Street Sweeper Bill SInger Jobs Wells Fargo Fraud U5 OBA Promissory Note Email U4 Guest Blog Guest Blogger Merrill Lynch BrokerAndBroker Wire Fraud UBS EFL Morgan Stanley Elderly Aegis Frumento Forbes FBI Defamation CRD Suitability PST Statutory Disqualification ALJ Ponzi Citigroup Whistleblower Rule 3270 Borrowing BrokerCheck Supervision DOJ Outside Business Activity Bank OIP IRS Felony Form U4 Willful SDNY Wachovia Wrongful Termination NAC BrokeAndBroker Expenses Pro Se Ameriprise Supreme Court Rule 2080 Mail Fraud IRA OHO Wife Insider Trading Husband Discretion WSP Rule 8210 Checks Dodd Frank Forgery Conversion CCO RIA Punitive Damages Form U5 Employment Tuesday Discovery NASD Bankruptcy Tax Settlement Madoff Raymond James Business Expenses Willfulness Estate Rule 3240 Rule 1122 Rule 3040 Frumento Rule 2010 Private Securities Transaction Credit Card JP Morgan Small Firm LPL NYSE Annuities Indictment Commissions Outside Business Activities Real Estate Power of Attorney Facebook 2Cir Bar Edward Jones Wall Street Impersonation Bank of America Corrective Action Statement Street Legal Spouse Rule 3280 Tax Lien Exam Beneficiary Promissory Notes ATM Mortgage ETF Margin SRO Wire Antitrust Complaint Case In Point Stephen Kohn Trust Injunction Schwab Tax Liens ARS Away Account Schapiro Appeal Rule 2510 CFTC Test Offer of Settlement Insurance T&P Signature Barclays NSF Misdemeanor Spouses Trustee Due Diligence Annuity Goldman Sachs VA Employee Forgivable Loan Options HFT Initial Decision Securities Fraud Loan Signatures NASAA Deutsche Bank Lien Conspiracy OTR Unauthorized Discretion Rule 12206 RBC POA Mandatory Arbitration PCAOB Bonus Remand Cease And Desist Money Laundering NASDAQ Great Recession DCCir Chase Fidelity Flash Crash Dissent Credit Cards Burris Trump email Compliance LOA E*Trade Stay InSecurities Continuing Education Rule 3010 Rule 4511 Huffington Post Eligibility Rule Blockchain Failure to Supervise Undisclosed Settlement Liens Disclosure Registered Rep Magazine Solicitation Variable Annuity Fiduciary Unsuitability Gallagher Sanctions Hacking Broker Protocol Rule 3050 Identity Theft Bharara Deceased RRBDLAW.com Securities Industry Commentator Lehman Brothers Unfair Competition OWB Scottrade Hacker MSSB JPMorgan Divorce ACQ Annual Compliance Questionnaire Sexist Stockbrokers Spoofing FINRA Arbitration Motion to Dismiss Customer Rule 4530 TRO Jurisdiction Audit Reg SP Board Wedbush Cryptocurrency Website Apple Explained Decision Letter of Authorization Forex Retirement brokeandbroker employment Malware Willfully Reimbursement Unauthorized Trading BrokeAndBroker Bill Singer Solicited Away Accounts arbitration Wey Registration Crypto LIBOR Will Internet Second Circuit 2nd Circuit Variable Annuities Customer Complaint Rule 12805 jobs Lehman Discrimination Self Regulation Elder Abuse Social Media Prison Sexism Vacatur Net Capital FINOP Confidential Information Plea BrokeAndBroker.com Blog Arbitraiton Retaliation Postponement Hedge Fund Unsolicited Bureau of Prisons Private Securities Transactions RMBS RRBDlaw.com Disgorgement Time And Price Hilton Weiner China Commission Newman Judgments Severance 10Cir Trading Platform MetLife BOP REIT Lucia Private Placement BrokeandBroker Stifel Charles Schwab Brummer IC3 9Cir Imposter Bonds Personal Expenses FOREX Zipper Telephone Mutual Funds Testimony Rakoff Marijuana Sanction Guidelines JOBS Act Auction Rate Securities Crowdfunding Rule 2111 Indemnification Stifel Nicolaus CE Check Kiting Piwowar MC-400 WSPs Emails Dakota Securities Unjust Enrichment FNMA Protocol Obstruction of Justice Statute of Limitations NYAG Botkin OSHA Rule 2150 Lawyer FAA IPO DOL ADA bill singer Rule 12200 Joshua Brown Loans Cheating Morgan Keegan Rule 3110 Suspension Debit Card Fees Bitcoin Examination TD Ameritrade Knight SAC Appointments Clause Check Passcode Motion to Vacate Public Interest PN Confirm Dementia Compensation TSSB MF Global Sales Assistant Pennystock Embezzlement Hurry Charge PNC Reg S-P EIA Board of Governors Wire Transfer Due Process AML Gold Restaurant Morgan Stanely Article V Conflict Whistleblowing TOD CRS Regulation SP Executor CPA Rule 2081 Raiding Medicare Non Solicitation Customer Information Confidential Affiliate Widow Oppenheimer Shah Gilani Class Action CEO Reg D Rule 13200 Wine Elder Fraud OIG High Frequency Trading Ketchum Bloomberg USERRA Puerto Rico Affinity Fraud Woody Allen Waiver Phishing Churning Banc of America Bandimere Khuzami Aleynikov Stanford Rule 13805 Rosenthal Recruiting CNBC Bear Stearns Rule 3030 Hearing Inability to Pay Commodities Fraud Online Vault Rule 2210 Casino Margin Call Membership Continuance Finder\'s Fee Eligibility PAQ Statutory Disqualification Committee Form ADV Rule 4513 Side Bar Teleconference Trade Secrets Unauthorized Practice of Law Bank Fraud Obstruction Star Wars Slander TCR Charity 6th Circuit Medical Condition Moon Ride the Thunder McDuff Vietnam Morgan Stanley Smith Barney Marine Corps Marines Whitman ING Unsuitable Self Regulatory Organization Penson SunTrust Accounting ACH Leveraged ETF Johnny Burris Smith Barney Government Accountability Project Statement of Corrective Action Yesenia Guitron Guitron White Subpoena Kon Unregistered Cannabis 401k Employment Agreement HSBC Disability NPR Marketplace Small Firm Governor Corruption Mutual Fund Parking Corzine Consent Order Private Placements Layering Bid Rigging Series 7 Testing Linde Murphy Outside Account Rule 9552 Poteroba Broke And Broker Pennystocks Written Supervisory Procedures David Sobel Day Trading Chief Compliance Officer Manifest Disregard Concentration Feigenbaum Termination Rule 12504 Deferred Compensation Federal Reserve Counterclaim Failure To Supervise Information Joint Account Aguilar Circuit Court Mother Laptop 11th Circuit Sharemaster Schneiderman Settling Away BD Research signature Chiasson Negligence Kokesh Oral Discretion JPM Thain Attorneys Fees Do Not Call Sexual Harassment Verbal Discretion Sexual Discrimination RRBDlaw Funds Rule 9216 Timban Meals Electronic Communications Inside Information PIABA CD Fowler Sarbanes Oxley WB-APP Rule 21F EDNY Amazon Resignation Motion Probate Privilege Nietzsche Trading Password Turnover Non-Solicitation Regulation Congress Control Person Outside Accounts Dell Commodities Money Market Counterfeit BATS Texting Rory Flynn Rule 12212 Chase Investment Services Arrest Rule 1031 IM Scottsdale Robert Cook Guest Bloggers Red Flags Ethereum Backstage Wall Street AXA Administrative Remedies 4Cir Libel Hospital Rule 2370 First Amendment Equity Indexed Annuities Fine Tax Fraud Standing Kiting Florida FINRA AWC OWWP Death Over Concentration SIFMA Elder Law Commissioner Stein 401(k) Stockbroker Excessive Trading David Lerner Investment Adviser CGMI YouTube Attorneys\' Fees BrokerAndBroker.com Google Credit Suisse Female Cold Spring Advisory Group BrokeAndbroker Escrow expungement Tortious Interference Jennifer Tarr TIC OCIE Stop Loss Judgment Investor Alert BrokeAndBroke Argentina Fines Fifth Amendment WaMu Third Party Vendor FOCUS VIX VXX Constitution Department of Justice 11Cir 9/11 Scholander IAR Client Information Elles Withdrawals Taft Correctional Institution Stipulated Award Netschi 40 Act Selling Away Lincoln Financial Moore Robert Muh Reverse Life Insurance Christian Stanley Wanger FCI FCI Beaumont TheBlot Inmate SP JPMorgan Chase Municipal Advisor 1099 Motion To Dismiss S&P Compliance Officer Regulation S-P Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker State Farm Merger GAP AAA Mary Jo White Irreparable Harm AWC. FINRA Hugh Hewitt Blank Forms Lee Customer Files Collateral Bar Theft Fourth Amendment Motion to Compel FINRA Small Firm Gabelli Proctor Reform Flash Drive NML Lawyers Offset Fiero Silver Diamonds DWI LLC Grievance Confidential Customer Information Rule 12904 Ethics Self Reporting Willfull Martoma Janney Montgomery Scott ADR Father BIll Singer Expense Bartko Evidence SEC Rules of Practice Schumer UIT Honorarium Anderson Finra Apartment Binary Options Sex Short Sale Books and Records Hertz Coin Bank Guarantee 10b-5 Galleon Stock Promotion Compromise Wires Constructive Discharge Stephen A. Kohn Transfer Capital Gains 9th Circuit Wells Fargo Advisors Talman Harris Wire Transfers iPhone Supervisor Dinner Koval Pruco Retroactive Taxes AIG Kenneth Starr Molchatsky Initials 1Cir Merrill SIPC Orders Daspin Retroactive Bar NYG Capital Murray Disciplinary History Credit Repair Pension Martin FNI Media false statements Disparate Treatment Advisor Placement Group Sharing Agreement Falsification Election FDA Kennedy House Financial Services Broy Nationwide Expert Witness BBVA Spam God Sears Currency Merill Lynch Reason for Termination Elon Musk Service CDO Promoter Liquidation Nasdaq Conflicts Turbeville FINRA Board National Securities Salman Powell Clayton BitTorrent Impersonator NY Life Bezos Section 206 Trader NoCA Oilpro Kent Respondeat Superior Summary Judgment Reuters Women ICO Fiduciary Duty Test Center Cherry Picking Lek Non-Prosecution Agreement Pacifico Kierkegaard Eric Stein Branch Manager Undertaking Newport Coast Securities Exception Reports Game of Thrones Production Exhaustion Doctrine MBS Compliance Questionnaire Rule 3210 Bill singer Jon Corzine Practice Sale Office of Special Counsel Checking Diabetes Preet Bharara Tran MSPB Wages Permanent Bar Unauthorized Trades Baby Boomers Laser Trainee Fee Mattera Romer Dow Data BrokeandBroker.com Undercover Criminal RICO Mary Schapiro McCartney Springsteen Skimming Guardian Puts Motion to Confirm Well Managed Portfolio FCPA Prime Bank Goble Naskovets RRBDLAW Subway Lexicon NFA Retired Woman With Cane Municipal Bonds Texas State Securities Board Newbridge SD Countrywide Life Settlement Life Insurance Brokeandbroker.com Obamacare Tennis Court FMLA Scam NRSRO Confirmation Books And Records Fee EDPA Risk Varney Rule 2330 Chevron Chase Bank Personal Information Payroll Travel Annual Audit PHC Microcap Collateral Leveraged ETFs Spoliation Johnson US Airways Cellphone Work Product 8210 Bribe Financial Disclosure Excel Statute of Limitation Walter Rules of Practice ADEA Sterne Agee Solomon Immunity Arbitration Reasonable Rule 3310 Witness Tampering Quasi Governmental Rule 420 Exotic ETF Relevant Securities and Exchange Commission State Actor Tippee Tipper Costa Rica In House Counsel Outside Counsel Customers Age Discrimination Bob Dylan FTC Altered Records Boyland Executrix Lewis Carroll Cybercrime Enforcement 17a-5 Mistake Reverse Merger ALJ Grimes CMO