An irreverent Wall Street Blog
by Bill Singer

David Lerner And Apple REITs Defendants In Stunning Class Action Victory

April 5, 2013

In a dramatic Eastern District of New York Opinion by Judge Matsumoto, the Apple REITs class action Defendants' Motion to Dismiss was granted. David Lerner Associates and the Apple REITs emerge victorious in this contentious and high-profile class action. 

Read the Memorandum and Order. In Re Apple REITs Litigation (EDNY,11-CV-2919, April 4, 2013). As the Court noted on page 44 of its Opinion:

Here, however, Plaintiffs have failed to proffer an actionable theory of loss.

In sum, Plaintiffs' belabored Complaint appears only to confirm that the Apple REITs are currently functioning in exactly the manner that was anticipated and disclosed in the REITs' prospectuses and other offering documents. . .

In similarly stark and dismissive language, the Court states on page 47 of its Opinion:

As the court previously discussed, Plaintiffs have failed to sufficiently plead any damages as a result of Defendants' purported misrepresentations or omissions with respect to the Apple REITs. To the contrary, the Complaint alleges that Plaintiffs have in fact consistently earned money from the Apple REITs. (See Compl. ¶ 183 (discussing the REITs' "consistent 7-8% distributions").) Accordingly, Plaintiffs' claim for common law breach of fiduciary duty must be and is dismissed.

Permalink

Search BrokeAndBroker

Related Topics

Previous Entries

Tag Cloud

Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker FINRA Arbitration AWC SEC BrokeAndBroker.com Expungement Employment Street Sweeper Jobs Bill SInger Wells Fargo OBA Fraud Promissory Note Email U5 U4 Wire Fraud Forbes UBS FBI Merrill Lynch Elderly EFL Statutory Disqualification PST Morgan Stanley ALJ Citigroup Defamation Borrowing Suitability Ponzi Rule 3270 Outside Business Activity OIP BrokerCheck Whistleblower IRS Supervision Wachovia Felony Form U4 CRD Bank Wrongful Termination Willful Mail Fraud DOJ Supreme Court SDNY NAC BrokerAndBroker Expenses Insider Trading Employment Tuesday CCO Form U5 Madoff Discretion Raymond James Bankruptcy Conversion Pro Se Ameriprise Checks Rule 3240 Credit Card Punitive Damages WSP Rule 3040 Forgery NASD OHO Private Securities Transaction Rule 2010 RIA Dodd Frank Rule 8210 IRA Indictment Willfulness Rule 1122 Real Estate JP Morgan Outside Business Activities Discovery Wall Street Street Legal Exam Guest Blog Commissions Settlement LPL Tax Wife NYSE Impersonation Husband ATM Tax Lien Power of Attorney Facebook Estate Rule 2080 Business Expenses Case In Point Antitrust Bar Stephen Kohn 2Cir Corrective Action Statement Edward Jones SRO Test Schapiro Wire Bank of America Appeal Annuities Margin Employee Forgivable Loan Tax Liens Rule 3280 Small Firm Schwab Rule 2510 Trust Mortgage Goldman Sachs Offer of Settlement Promissory Notes HFT Spouse Securities Fraud Complaint Conspiracy Trustee Misdemeanor NSF NASAA ETF ARS Signatures Initial Decision Beneficiary Signature T&P Fidelity Lien Loan Chase Cease And Desist Flash Crash Injunction Barclays VA NASDAQ Due Diligence LOA CFTC Money Laundering BrokeAndBroker Annuity Huffington Post Credit Cards PCAOB Away Account Hacker email Identity Theft Failure to Supervise Lehman Brothers Unauthorized Discretion Bharara Continuing Education Liens DCCir MSSB Compliance Unfair Competition Deutsche Bank Bonus OTR Remand Variable Annuity POA Gallagher Registered Rep Magazine RBC RRBDLAW.com Annual Compliance Questionnaire Spouses Wedbush Eligibility Rule Forex Rule 3010 Stockbrokers FINRA Arbitration Malware Letter of Authorization Burris Guest Blogger Solicitation Mandatory Arbitration E*Trade employment Registration Scottrade Away Accounts Undisclosed Settlement Solicited Fiduciary jobs Rule 3050 Audit Stay Prison LIBOR Hacking 2nd Circuit Insurance Website Net Capital Options Rule 12206 Social Media Wey Second Circuit arbitration JPMorgan Rule 12805 TRO 10Cir Customer Complaint Plea Great Recession Bureau of Prisons Reg SP Newman Will Unsolicited BrokeAndBroker Bill Singer Time And Price brokeandbroker Trading Platform FOREX Telephone IC3 FINOP Private Securities Transactions Brummer Internet Retirement Rule 4511 Private Placement RRBDlaw.com Broker Protocol Rule 4530 Judgments BOP Obstruction of Justice Check Kiting DOL ADA Spoofing Dissent Rakoff Explained Decision Examination RMBS Disclosure MetLife Cheating Knight Rule 2111 REIT Motion to Dismiss Hedge Fund Willfully Piwowar China Self Regulation Sanctions BrokeandBroker Unauthorized Trading Divorce NYAG Auction Rate Securities Confidential Information OWB Apple Protocol Phishing Hurry bill singer Woody Allen Khuzami Vacatur Due Process Rule 2081 Morgan Keegan Lehman OSHA Postponement 9Cir Wine Class Action Affiliate Arbitraiton Discrimination Stifel Regulation SP Confidential Medicare Raiding Gold Affinity Fraud Reg D Retaliation Commission Aleynikov Customer Bandimere SAC Joshua Brown Executor Sanction Guidelines Waiver Wire Transfer Botkin Variable Annuities Article V Deceased Debit Card PN PNC Sexist MF Global Charge IPO Banc of America Disgorgement Ketchum EIA High Frequency Trading Passcode Shah Gilani Unsuitability Reimbursement Crowdfunding Board Marines Bid Rigging Smith Barney Oppenheimer ING HSBC Rule 13805 Reg S-P Ride the Thunder Zipper 401k ACQ Vietnam Whitman Marijuana Deferred Compensation Lawyer Corruption Guitron Stifel Nicolaus Eligibility Yesenia Guitron Rosenthal Recruiting Corzine Online Government Accountability Project Johnny Burris Poteroba Testimony Marine Corps Casino Charity Vault Dakota Securities Stanford Aguilar Charles Schwab Pennystocks Suspension Indemnification Morgan Stanely Loans Appointments Clause Statement of Corrective Action Compensation Failure To Supervise Information AML White Parking JOBS Act Mutual Fund OIG Small Firm Governor Whistleblowing Laptop Chief Compliance Officer Penson Rule 12200 Embezzlement Widow Morgan Stanley Smith Barney Unjust Enrichment 6th Circuit WSPs Bank Fraud MC-400 Rule 2150 Commodities Fraud Side Bar CEO Sexism Private Placements Sales Assistant Personal Expenses McDuff Finder\'s Fee Jurisdiction Self Regulatory Organization Fees Check Testing Series 7 Statute of Limitations Teleconference Confirm Rule 3030 Kon Marketplace USERRA Consent Order Lucia Pennystock Bear Stearns Bloomberg Conflict Hearing NPR Disability Termination Employment Agreement CE Unregistered Customer Information Day Trading Emails Form ADV Negligence Rule 2210 Medical Condition Fowler Investment Adviser FOCUS BD 401(k) Timban IAR FINRA AWC Frumento Inside Information Taft Correctional Institution Scholander Stockbroker Bonds Margin Call Research Oral Discretion Thain Client Information Chiasson Sexual Harassment Elles RRBDlaw Mutual Funds 11th Circuit Probate Do Not Call SP TheBlot Department of Justice Verbal Discretion Female Rule 9216 Rule 3110 Equity Indexed Annuities Tax Fraud Dementia Stipulated Award Sharemaster Rule 2370 FCI Beaumont Feigenbaum Outside Accounts Imposter Rule 1031 Written Supervisory Procedures TSSB Layering Dell Hospital Red Flags Fine Guest Bloggers Backstage Wall Street 40 Act Administrative Remedies 4Cir Scottsdale CPA Outside Account Circuit Court TIC Hilton Weiner Inability to Pay Unauthorized Practice of Law Moon Credit Suisse CGMI Fifth Amendment Argentina OWWP Christian Stanley WaMu Judgment Investor Alert Trade Secrets Tortious Interference Non-Solicitation Restaurant FCI OCIE FNMA Commodities Florida Elder Abuse BATS Reverse Life Insurance Arrest Chase Investment Services Leveraged ETF Schneiderman Broke And Broker David Sobel Severance Third Party Vendor Lincoln Financial Accounting Counterclaim Moore Netschi expungement CNBC Churning TD Ameritrade BrokerAndBroker.com Inmate Countrywide Exhaustion Doctrine Rule 420 Subpoena Tran Proctor Spoliation Martin Sexual Discrimination Pacifico Solomon Reverse Merger Regulation Rule 9552 Quasi Governmental Privilege Non-Prosecution Agreement RRBDLAW Bank Guarantee Leveraged ETFs Oilpro Membership Continuance Kent Cannabis AXA Blank Forms Trader Resignation Standing Commissioner Stein Customer Files Summary Judgment Relevant SunTrust Statutory Disqualification Committee Non Solicitation Cherry Picking Collateral Office of Special Counsel Retroactive Compliance Officer Reform Mary Jo White Broy BitTorrent Aegis Frumento Varney Salman BBVA S&P Motion To Dismiss Death Electronic Communications FINRA Board Board of Governors Altered Records Merger Regulation S-P Personal Information Impersonator ACH Tippee Tipper Liquidation Motion to Vacate Municipal Advisor NRSRO Bartko JPM Collateral Bar Retroactive Bar NYG Capital Excel In House Counsel Securities and Exchange Commission Gabelli US Airways Ethics Lawyers Fourth Amendment FMLA Attorneys Fees 8210 Cellphone Currency Johnson Public Interest FNI Media Advisor Placement Group Joint Account Mother Fines Fiero DWI Subway Enforcement Motion FCPA Prime Bank BrokeAndBroke Euro Expense Apartment Settling Away GAP Promoter Pension Constructive Discharge Laser Rule 13200 Disciplinary History Criminal FDA Texting Dinner iPhone Counterfeit Checking FINRA Small Firm Jon Corzine Kiting BrokeandBroker.com Supervisor Mary Schapiro Compromise Hugh Hewitt AWC. FINRA Wells Fargo Advisors Koval Texas State Securities Board Selling Away Short Sale Preet Bharara SD EDNY Stock Promotion CDO Murray Attorneys\' Fees Merrill Taxes David Lerner Anderson Lee Fiduciary Duty Kenneth Starr Test Center Federal Reserve Initials Chevron Annual Audit 17a-5 Outside Counsel Nasdaq Reuters signature Grievance 1Cir Rule 4513 PAQ Star Wars Falsification Sharing Agreement Elder Fraud Naskovets false statements Unsuitable Flash Drive Stephen A. Kohn Books and Records Obstruction God Skimming Immunity Lek Theft House Financial Services Disparate Treatment Undertaking Pruco Branch Manager Eric Stein Credit Repair Scam Nationwide Concentration Walter Evidence Obamacare 1099 Schumer Dow Springsteen McCartney Wanger CRS Diabetes Books And Records SEC Rules of Practice Password Trading Boyland Lewis Carroll Congress Martoma Google 9th Circuit Stop Loss Fee Money Market Reason for Termination Spam TOD NFA Mattera Rules of Practice Kennedy Escrow Undercover Hertz Compliance Questionnaire AIG Trainee Fee Customers Data SIPC LLC Bribe NML Cybercrime Manifest Disregard Sex Silver Wages Payroll Brokeandbroker.com Retired Woman With Cane Tennis Court Galleon Practice Sale Withdrawals Permanent Bar FTC Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker VIX PIABA VXX Over Concentration Executrix Costa Rica Turbeville Goble