An irreverent Wall Street Blog
by Bill Singer

419 Retirement Plan Taxes Claimants in Wells Fargo Arbitration

July 3, 2013

In a Financial Industry Regulatory Authority ("FINRA") Arbitration Statement of Claim filed in April 2012, Claimants Saunders asserted fraudulent inducement, negligent misrepresentations, and breach of fiduciary duty in connection with alleged recommendations by the respondents concerning the creation of an employer-sponsored welfare benefit plan under §419 of the Internal Revenue Code. Claimants alleged that the recommended retirement vehicle was unsuitable and that they had not been advised by respondents of potential tax liabilities.  By the close of the hearing, Claimants sought $290,476.22 in compensatory damages plus punitive damages, interest, attorneys' fees, and costs. In the Matter of the FINRA Arbitration Between Michael Saunders and Yvonne Saunders, Claimants, vs. Wells Fargo Investments, LLC, John Wingate, Adam Suhr, Ross Friend, Strategic Financial Concepts, LLC, and Russell McNorton, Jr., Respondents (FINRA Arbitration 12-01470, June 21, 2013 ).


Respondents Wells Fargo Investments ("WFI"), Wingate, Suhr, Friend, and Strategic Financial Concepts ("SFI") generally denied the allegations and asserted various affirmative defenses. Additionally, the FINRA Arbitration Panel was asked to expunge the arbitration from the Central Registration Depository records ("CRD") of respondents Wingate, Suhr and Friend.

Arbitration Housekeeping

The FINRA Arbitration Panel determined that Respondent Russell McNorton, Jr. had not been properly served with the Statement of Claim or received due notice of the hearing.

After Claimants had presented their case-in-chief, around June 13, 2013, the Panel granted Respondent SFI's Motion To Dismiss.

Decision

The FINRA Arbitration Panel found Respondents WFI and Friend jointly and severally liable and ordered them to pay to Claimants  $75,000.00 in compensatory damages and $300 as reimbursement for FINRA's filing fee.

The Panel dismissed Respondent McNorton without prejudice.

The Panel dismissed Respondent Wingate with prejudice.

Expungements

The Panel denied the requested expungements of the CRDs or respondents Wingate and Friend.

The Panel recommended the expungement of the matter from the CRD of Respondent Suhr after finding that he had not been involved in the sale of the 419 plan product to Claimants. As explained in the Decision:

[L]ater, when Wells Fargo asked Mr. Suhr to try to help Claimants, Mr. Suhr provided the claimants with a possible solution to Claimants' concerns. However, Claimants decided not to act on the possible solution that was raised by Mr. Suhr. . .

SIDE BAR With Bill Singer (Thomson Reuters)
Is Self Regulation A Dinosaur on Wall Street? (8:51 run time) 

Martin Kaplan, Esq. explains the significance of his landmark victory in Fiero v. FINRA. Kaplan and Bill Singer, Esq. discuss whether FINRA is now a toothless tiger. 

READ: "FINRA Loses Landmark Federal Appeals Case on Collection of Fines" (BrokeAndBroker.com, October 7, 2011)

NEW EPISODE OF 
SIDE BAR WITH BILL SINGER 
NOW ONLINE
Martin Kaplan, Esq. Talks About FINRA

REUTERS.COM


YouTube for iPhone/Pad Users


Permalink

Search BrokeAndBroker

Related Topics

Previous Entries

Tag Cloud

Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker FINRA Arbitration AWC SEC BrokeAndBroker.com Expungement Employment Street Sweeper Jobs Bill SInger Wells Fargo Fraud OBA Promissory Note Email U5 U4 Wire Fraud Forbes FBI UBS Merrill Lynch Elderly EFL Morgan Stanley ALJ Statutory Disqualification Citigroup PST Defamation Ponzi Borrowing Rule 3270 Outside Business Activity Suitability OIP Whistleblower BrokerCheck Wachovia IRS Supervision Form U4 Felony Bank CRD Wrongful Termination Willful Mail Fraud DOJ NAC SDNY Supreme Court Insider Trading Employment Tuesday Expenses BrokerAndBroker Form U5 Conversion Raymond James Madoff Ameriprise Discretion Bankruptcy Rule 3040 Punitive Damages Pro Se Forgery CCO Checks Credit Card Rule 3240 OHO RIA WSP Rule 2010 Dodd Frank JP Morgan Outside Business Activities Private Securities Transaction Indictment IRA Real Estate Discovery NASD Willfulness Rule 1122 Settlement Tax Commissions Exam Street Legal LPL Rule 8210 Facebook Power of Attorney Wife NYSE Estate ATM Bar Case In Point Wall Street Impersonation 2Cir Guest Blog Husband Business Expenses Tax Lien Corrective Action Statement Small Firm Wire SRO Schapiro Test Stephen Kohn Edward Jones Antitrust Bank of America Rule 2080 Appeal Employee Forgivable Loan Annuities Trust Schwab Goldman Sachs Mortgage Tax Liens Margin Offer of Settlement Rule 3280 HFT ETF Promissory Notes NASAA Spouse Trustee ARS Conspiracy Rule 2510 Securities Fraud Misdemeanor Fidelity Injunction Beneficiary Initial Decision Signatures Complaint T&P NSF Loan Flash Crash Chase Cease And Desist Barclays Due Diligence Signature VA Money Laundering Huffington Post Lien NASDAQ LOA Away Account Bharara BrokeAndBroker Liens Deutsche Bank Hacker MSSB Gallagher Remand Variable Annuity Registered Rep Magazine DCCir Credit Cards Bonus Lehman Brothers Continuing Education POA RBC RRBDLAW.com Unfair Competition CFTC Annuity Identity Theft FINRA Arbitration Eligibility Rule PCAOB Solicitation E*Trade email Annual Compliance Questionnaire employment Unauthorized Discretion Letter of Authorization Forex Malware Mandatory Arbitration OTR Scottrade LIBOR Undisclosed Settlement Prison Spouses Rule 3010 Stockbrokers Fiduciary Insurance Wey Net Capital Stay Failure to Supervise Hacking 2nd Circuit arbitration Rule 12206 JPMorgan Second Circuit Registration Social Media jobs Away Accounts Rule 3050 Wedbush Website Customer Complaint FINOP Judgments BOP Audit Burris Will Solicited Brummer Time And Price Bureau of Prisons Trading Platform Guest Blogger Reg SP Retirement RRBDlaw.com Private Placement Broker Protocol IC3 FOREX 10Cir Internet Compliance Private Securities Transactions Great Recession Rule 4511 Telephone Options Newman TRO BrokeandBroker Rakoff Plea RMBS Apple Willfully Spoofing brokeandbroker Explained Decision China Self Regulation NYAG Piwowar Rule 4530 Sanctions Confidential Information Hedge Fund MetLife Unsolicited BrokeAndBroker Bill Singer Rule 12805 Cheating Auction Rate Securities DOL Knight Unauthorized Trading Examination Rule 2111 Divorce OWB Protocol Obstruction of Justice Dissent ADA Reg D Crowdfunding Sexist Variable Annuities Morgan Keegan Discrimination Wire Transfer Khuzami Check Kiting High Frequency Trading Motion to Dismiss Medicare Phishing Customer Hurry Charge Lehman Commission Disgorgement Aleynikov Executor EIA Wine Bandimere SAC Raiding Vacatur Affiliate Arbitraiton Unsuitability Gold Board Article V Class Action PNC Disclosure REIT Due Process IPO Retaliation PN Regulation SP Postponement Ketchum OSHA Woody Allen Affinity Fraud MF Global Debit Card Joshua Brown Shah Gilani Confidential Banc of America Sanction Guidelines Passcode Botkin Mutual Fund Reimbursement Embezzlement Unjust Enrichment Corzine Smith Barney MC-400 Government Accountability Project Compensation Series 7 Bloomberg Private Placements 401k Customer Information ACQ Guitron NPR Online Charles Schwab Stifel Poteroba Yesenia Guitron Corruption Marketplace Whitman Casino bill singer Confirm HSBC Reg S-P Widow Commodities Fraud Day Trading McDuff Testimony Stanford Check Rule 12200 WSPs Finder\'s Fee Fees Rule 2081 Penson CEO Hearing Eligibility Pennystock Parking Failure To Supervise Rosenthal Recruiting Bid Rigging Rule 3030 Chief Compliance Officer Charity OIG Pennystocks Indemnification Appointments Clause Information Kon Conflict Bear Stearns Lucia Laptop ING Morgan Stanley Smith Barney Lawyer Statute of Limitations Jurisdiction Aguilar Testing Oppenheimer Termination Deceased JOBS Act USERRA Personal Expenses CE Statement of Corrective Action 6th Circuit Vault Deferred Compensation Morgan Stanely Sales Assistant White Self Regulatory Organization Whistleblowing Disability Waiver Bank Fraud Teleconference Employment Agreement Unregistered Marines 9Cir Ride the Thunder Vietnam Marine Corps Sexism Side Bar 40 Act TheBlot Layering Guest Bloggers Chase Investment Services Red Flags Outside Account Emails FOCUS Tortious Interference Timban Dakota Securities Rule 9216 Department of Justice Schneiderman Zipper CPA Investor Alert OCIE TD Ameritrade Written Supervisory Procedures Trade Secrets Backstage Wall Street Consent Order WaMu Judgment Elles Arrest Thain Medical Condition Inmate Stipulated Award Severance Rule 3110 Scholander Florida Leveraged ETF 11th Circuit Small Firm Governor Hospital Dell Rule 2150 Rule 13805 BATS Margin Call Loans Credit Suisse Taft Correctional Institution TSSB FCI Beaumont Female Outside Accounts Verbal Discretion Fowler expungement Rule 1031 Stockbroker CNBC Suspension Unauthorized Practice of Law RRBDlaw FINRA AWC Commodities Non-Solicitation Restaurant Stifel Nicolaus Equity Indexed Annuities CGMI Broke And Broker Imposter Investment Adviser Accounting David Sobel Moon Third Party Vendor SP 401(k) Fifth Amendment OWWP Argentina TIC Probate Sexual Harassment FCI Do Not Call Circuit Court 4Cir Administrative Remedies Johnny Burris Form ADV Rule 2210 Securities Industry Commentator Scottsdale Netschi Moore Research BrokerAndBroker.com Christian Stanley IAR Chiasson Frumento Bonds FNMA Lincoln Financial Rule 2370 Tax Fraud Reverse Life Insurance AML Client Information Dementia Negligence Counterclaim Inside Information Elder Abuse FMLA Euro Enforcement Fiduciary Duty Solomon Rule 9552 Payroll US Airways Cellphone Schumer Johnson Fourth Amendment Dow Diabetes JPM Non Solicitation Motion FCPA Wages Joint Account Walter Mother Wells Fargo Advisors 8210 Disciplinary History Prime Bank Subway Immunity Reverse Merger Hugh Hewitt false statements NYG Capital Broy Springsteen Retroactive Branch Manager Eric Stein Falsification Compromise FINRA Small Firm Fine Mary Jo White Municipal Advisor Costa Rica Retroactive Bar Regulation S-P Supervisor 1Cir Collateral Bar SunTrust Death Books and Records iPhone Texas State Securities Board Obstruction God House Financial Services FTC Short Sale NRSRO Rule 420 Promoter Stock Promotion Varney AWC. FINRA Motion To Dismiss Pension S&P Flash Drive Quasi Governmental Scam Salman Elder Fraud Boyland EDNY Undertaking Sharing Agreement Spoliation McCartney Bartko Personal Information Constructive Discharge FNI Media Practice Sale Aegis Frumento CDO Sexual Discrimination Apartment Liquidation Stop Loss Currency Impersonator Lek Sex Membership Continuance Data Koval Statutory Disqualification Committee Naskovets Skimming Blank Forms FDA Churning BitTorrent Inability to Pay Expense PAQ CRS Advisor Placement Group Office of Special Counsel Pacifico Non-Prosecution Agreement Galleon Executrix Public Interest Attorneys Fees Exhaustion Doctrine Withdrawals Marijuana PIABA Lewis Carroll Commissioner Stein Selling Away Pruco NML signature TOD FINRA Board LLC 9th Circuit DWI Undercover Privilege Excel Customer Files Criminal Rules of Practice BBVA BrokeAndBroke Cybercrime Taxes Fiero Fines Compliance Questionnaire Mattera Initials Lee Concentration Laser Mary Schapiro Merrill Attorneys\' Fees Disparate Treatment Standing Murray Oral Discretion Kenneth Starr Theft Kennedy Relevant ACH BrokeandBroker.com Leveraged ETFs Securities and Exchange Commission Collateral Anderson Trainee Fee Escrow Manifest Disregard Money Market Kiting Subpoena SIPC AIG Outside Counsel BD Hertz Checking Martoma Reform Reason for Termination Google 1099 Turbeville Altered Records Jon Corzine Summary Judgment Star Wars Wanger GAP Goble Reuters Congress Counterfeit Over Concentration Bribe Rule 13200 Password Obamacare Trading RRBDLAW Settling Away Permanent Bar Resignation Test Center Books And Records Preet Bharara Mutual Funds Tran Motion to Vacate Kent In House Counsel Martin Oilpro Retired Woman With Cane Spam Countrywide Silver Credit Repair Brokeandbroker.com Federal Reserve Fee Cherry Picking Board of Governors David Lerner Trader Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker VXX SEC Rules of Practice Gabelli VIX Nationwide Customers Nasdaq Proctor Evidence Tennis Court Tippee Tipper AXA Electronic Communications Lawyers Bank Guarantee