An irreverent Wall Street Blog
by Bill Singer

419 Retirement Plan Taxes Claimants in Wells Fargo Arbitration

July 3, 2013

In a Financial Industry Regulatory Authority ("FINRA") Arbitration Statement of Claim filed in April 2012, Claimants Saunders asserted fraudulent inducement, negligent misrepresentations, and breach of fiduciary duty in connection with alleged recommendations by the respondents concerning the creation of an employer-sponsored welfare benefit plan under §419 of the Internal Revenue Code. Claimants alleged that the recommended retirement vehicle was unsuitable and that they had not been advised by respondents of potential tax liabilities.  By the close of the hearing, Claimants sought $290,476.22 in compensatory damages plus punitive damages, interest, attorneys' fees, and costs. In the Matter of the FINRA Arbitration Between Michael Saunders and Yvonne Saunders, Claimants, vs. Wells Fargo Investments, LLC, John Wingate, Adam Suhr, Ross Friend, Strategic Financial Concepts, LLC, and Russell McNorton, Jr., Respondents (FINRA Arbitration 12-01470, June 21, 2013 ).


Respondents Wells Fargo Investments ("WFI"), Wingate, Suhr, Friend, and Strategic Financial Concepts ("SFI") generally denied the allegations and asserted various affirmative defenses. Additionally, the FINRA Arbitration Panel was asked to expunge the arbitration from the Central Registration Depository records ("CRD") of respondents Wingate, Suhr and Friend.

Arbitration Housekeeping

The FINRA Arbitration Panel determined that Respondent Russell McNorton, Jr. had not been properly served with the Statement of Claim or received due notice of the hearing.

After Claimants had presented their case-in-chief, around June 13, 2013, the Panel granted Respondent SFI's Motion To Dismiss.

Decision

The FINRA Arbitration Panel found Respondents WFI and Friend jointly and severally liable and ordered them to pay to Claimants  $75,000.00 in compensatory damages and $300 as reimbursement for FINRA's filing fee.

The Panel dismissed Respondent McNorton without prejudice.

The Panel dismissed Respondent Wingate with prejudice.

Expungements

The Panel denied the requested expungements of the CRDs or respondents Wingate and Friend.

The Panel recommended the expungement of the matter from the CRD of Respondent Suhr after finding that he had not been involved in the sale of the 419 plan product to Claimants. As explained in the Decision:

[L]ater, when Wells Fargo asked Mr. Suhr to try to help Claimants, Mr. Suhr provided the claimants with a possible solution to Claimants' concerns. However, Claimants decided not to act on the possible solution that was raised by Mr. Suhr. . .

SIDE BAR With Bill Singer (Thomson Reuters)
Is Self Regulation A Dinosaur on Wall Street? (8:51 run time) 

Martin Kaplan, Esq. explains the significance of his landmark victory in Fiero v. FINRA. Kaplan and Bill Singer, Esq. discuss whether FINRA is now a toothless tiger. 

READ: "FINRA Loses Landmark Federal Appeals Case on Collection of Fines" (BrokeAndBroker.com, October 7, 2011)

NEW EPISODE OF 
SIDE BAR WITH BILL SINGER 
NOW ONLINE
Martin Kaplan, Esq. Talks About FINRA

REUTERS.COM


YouTube for iPhone/Pad Users


Permalink

Search BrokeAndBroker

Related Topics

Previous Entries

Tag Cloud

Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker FINRA Arbitration AWC SEC BrokeAndBroker.com Expungement Employment Street Sweeper Bill SInger Jobs Wells Fargo OBA Fraud U5 Promissory Note Email U4 Wire Fraud UBS Forbes Merrill Lynch FBI Elderly Morgan Stanley Statutory Disqualification EFL PST ALJ Defamation Suitability Citigroup CRD Borrowing Ponzi Rule 3270 BrokerCheck Outside Business Activity Whistleblower OIP IRS Supervision Form U4 Wachovia Felony Willful Bank DOJ Wrongful Termination Guest Blog Mail Fraud Supreme Court NAC Expenses SDNY BrokerAndBroker Ameriprise CCO Discretion Insider Trading Form U5 Employment Tuesday Pro Se Checks Madoff Conversion IRA Punitive Damages OHO Bankruptcy Raymond James WSP Credit Card Willfulness Rule 3040 Rule 2080 Rule 3240 NASD Dodd Frank Forgery Tax Discovery Private Securities Transaction Guest Blogger Wife Husband Rule 8210 Rule 1122 RIA Rule 2010 Indictment Real Estate Estate JP Morgan Outside Business Activities Settlement Exam Commissions Street Legal Business Expenses LPL Power of Attorney Wall Street NYSE Tax Lien Annuities ATM Facebook Impersonation Edward Jones Stephen Kohn Bank of America Small Firm Antitrust Bar 2Cir Rule 3280 Corrective Action Statement Mortgage Case In Point Wire Margin Schapiro Appeal Test BrokeAndBroker Tax Liens SRO NSF Spouse ARS Employee Forgivable Loan Frumento Offer of Settlement Beneficiary Complaint Trust Goldman Sachs Rule 2510 Schwab Conspiracy ETF Misdemeanor Securities Fraud Trustee Signatures HFT Promissory Notes NASAA Chase Lien Due Diligence Fidelity Injunction Loan T&P Signature Initial Decision PCAOB Cease And Desist RBC Flash Crash VA Unauthorized Discretion Deutsche Bank Credit Cards Annuity Money Laundering NASDAQ DCCir CFTC LOA POA Huffington Post Barclays Away Account Identity Theft Burris Unfair Competition Gallagher Variable Annuity Scottrade RRBDLAW.com Insurance Failure to Supervise Spouses Bharara Lehman Brothers Hacker Remand Mandatory Arbitration Compliance Continuing Education OTR MSSB email Registered Rep Magazine Bonus Stay Liens Fiduciary E*Trade Malware Rule 12206 Stockbrokers Letter of Authorization Audit FINRA Arbitration Options Rule 3010 employment Undisclosed Settlement Forex Solicitation JPMorgan Eligibility Rule Annual Compliance Questionnaire Great Recession Wedbush Solicited BrokeAndBroker Bill Singer LIBOR 2nd Circuit Wey Customer Complaint FINOP Rule 12805 Customer Second Circuit Away Accounts Website Hacking brokeandbroker TRO Retirement jobs Disclosure arbitration Net Capital Will Social Media Aegis Frumento Prison Registration Rule 3050 BrokeandBroker RRBDlaw.com Brummer Plea IC3 Zipper Telephone Newman Lehman Judgments Dissent Private Placement Reg SP Broker Protocol Rule 4511 Reimbursement Apple Time And Price Trading Platform RMBS Unauthorized Trading BOP OWB Unsuitability China Sanctions Bureau of Prisons Private Securities Transactions FOREX Rule 4530 Unsolicited Willfully Internet 10Cir Motion to Dismiss Crowdfunding Variable Annuities Obstruction of Justice Divorce NYAG Lucia Spoofing Commission Disgorgement Auction Rate Securities MC-400 Dakota Securities Rakoff Explained Decision Self Regulation Rule 12200 FNMA REIT ADA Arbitraiton Stifel Personal Expenses Examination Confidential Information MetLife Check Kiting Protocol Piwowar DOL Hedge Fund Deceased Rule 2111 Knight WSPs Cheating Wine Debit Card Churning Compensation Charge JOBS Act SAC Article V Wire Transfer Hurry EIA Conflict Joshua Brown PNC Bandimere Postponement Retaliation Phishing Botkin Fees Passcode Ketchum Stifel Nicolaus Regulation SP Rule 2150 Emails Bonds Jurisdiction Woody Allen Appointments Clause Lawyer Shah Gilani 9Cir OSHA PN Affiliate Khuzami Banc of America Aleynikov bill singer Vacatur Affinity Fraud Indemnification Morgan Keegan Discrimination Executor MF Global Confidential IPO Class Action Medicare Stanford Gold Reg D Sanction Guidelines Due Process Rule 2081 Sexist High Frequency Trading OIG Hilton Weiner Board Raiding Waiver Elder Abuse Rule 3110 Online Small Firm Governor Statute of Limitations Puerto Rico Consent Order Marijuana Chief Compliance Officer Eligibility Membership Continuance Rule 3030 Oppenheimer ACQ Charles Schwab Laptop AML Charity Loans 401k Corruption USERRA Hearing TD Ameritrade CE NPR Marketplace Series 7 Written Supervisory Procedures Smith Barney Unregistered Rosenthal Recruiting SunTrust Vault Kon Parking Bloomberg Concentration Teleconference Customer Information Imposter Termination Pennystocks Mutual Fund Disability Bear Stearns Securities Industry Commentator Confirm ING Penson Ride the Thunder Dementia Accounting Corzine Whistleblowing Vietnam Marines Widow Finder\'s Fee Testing 6th Circuit Bid Rigging Marine Corps Rule 13805 Deferred Compensation Commodities Fraud Suspension Sales Assistant HSBC Day Trading Reg S-P Side Bar Employment Agreement Testimony Aguilar Bank Fraud Pennystock Embezzlement Unjust Enrichment Casino Sexism Restaurant Guitron Government Accountability Project Check Whitman Poteroba Morgan Stanely Statement of Corrective Action Private Placements Mutual Funds Self Regulatory Organization White Johnny Burris Statutory Disqualification Committee Yesenia Guitron Failure To Supervise Morgan Stanley Smith Barney McDuff CEO Information Red Flags Robert Cook 4Cir Guest Bloggers Counterfeit Administrative Remedies Fowler Sexual Harassment Fifth Amendment Feigenbaum Fine Florida RRBDlaw Elles OCIE Unsuitable Kiting Hospital Department of Justice TSSB Do Not Call Thain OWWP CGMI Backstage Wall Street PAQ Outside Account Layering Dell Inmate WaMu BrokeAndBroker.com Blog Mother TIC Sharemaster Moon Scottsdale 40 Act Client Information Rule 2210 Unauthorized Practice of Law Form ADV Female IAR Counterclaim Inability to Pay Investor Alert Stop Loss Argentina Broke And Broker David Sobel Probate Oral Discretion Third Party Vendor TheBlot BATS CNBC SP ACH Scholander Tortious Interference Stipulated Award Inside Information Credit Suisse Margin Call Trade Secrets Judgment Settling Away 11th Circuit Schneiderman Chiasson Research Christian Stanley Taft Correctional Institution Commissioner Stein 401(k) Negligence Verbal Discretion Stockbroker Investment Adviser Motion to Vacate Severance Reverse Life Insurance Timban Over Concentration Motion FOCUS expungement Medical Condition Star Wars Leveraged ETF FINRA AWC FCI FCI Beaumont BrokerAndBroker.com Arrest signature Rule 2370 Rule 9216 Moore CRS BD Rule 1031 Outside Accounts Board of Governors TOD Equity Indexed Annuities Circuit Court CPA Congress Tax Fraud Lincoln Financial Netschi Non-Solicitation Chase Investment Services Commodities Federal Reserve AAA Compromise Short Sale CD Rule 12504 Wires US Airways Supervisor JPM Dinner EDNY iPhone Wire Transfers Cellphone Johnson Expense BrokeAndBroke Flash Drive Rules of Practice Electronic Communications PIABA Bill singer Pruco Executrix FDA FINRA Small Firm AWC. FINRA Disparate Treatment Lewis Carroll Hugh Hewitt Altered Records Office of Special Counsel Cybercrime 8210 Fines Fiero Wells Fargo Advisors Tippee Tipper DWI Public Interest Stock Promotion Customers false statements Collateral Advisor Placement Group Leveraged ETFs Privilege Books And Records Travel Rule 4513 Chase Bank Grievance Payroll Fee Excel Willfull Immunity Risk Bank Guarantee Martin Sexual Discrimination Spoliation Credit Repair Attorneys Fees Resignation Merrill Attorneys\' Fees Fiduciary Duty Obstruction Books and Records Theft Falsification Rule 9552 Solomon Elder Fraud Rule 13200 Sharing Agreement Quasi Governmental GAP Rule 420 Enforcement Reverse Merger Scam Anderson ADR BrokeAndbroker Lee Constructive Discharge CMO Non Solicitation Preet Bharara Goble MBS Password Money Market Obamacare Test Center Reuters Turbeville 17a-5 FINRA Board Annual Audit Chevron Conflicts Nasdaq Springsteen McCartney Expert Witness Nationwide Data Trainee Fee Laser Manifest Disregard Reason for Termination Lek Newport Coast Securities Wages Practice Sale Financial Disclosure Undercover Escrow Impersonator BitTorrent Retroactive Exhaustion Doctrine Retroactive Bar Collateral Bar NRSRO Municipal Advisor NYG Capital FNI Media Currency Cannabis Merill Lynch Subpoena Pacifico Non-Prosecution Agreement Bartko Cherry Picking Liquidation Trader In House Counsel Summary Judgment Salman Outside Counsel Relevant AXA BBVA Constitution Service Oilpro FMLA Mattera Kennedy SD Compliance Officer Wanger Permanent Bar S&P Motion To Dismiss Mary Jo White Texas State Securities Board Merger Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker Retired Woman With Cane Tennis Court Death Regulation S-P Fourth Amendment Gabelli Excessive Trading 1Cir Jon Corzine Initials David Lerner Taxes Customer Files Blank Forms Texting Withdrawals Proctor TCR Checking Puts State Farm Evidence Silver CDO SEC Rules of Practice Promoter Stephen A. Kohn NML God Cold Spring Advisory Group Undertaking LLC Eric Stein Jennifer Tarr Branch Manager Google Apartment Disciplinary History Subway Prime Bank BIll Singer Elder Law FCPA Trading Joint Account Martoma Janney Montgomery Scott Pension Compliance Questionnaire Father Molchatsky Kent Brokeandbroker.com NFA Spam Ethics Baby Boomers Diabetes Countrywide Personal Information Tran Dow Regulation Lawyers SIPC House Financial Services Broy AIG Standing Rory Flynn RRBDLAW VXX 1099 MSPB Walter Criminal SIFMA Nietzsche 9/11 Newbridge Boyland Sex Statute of Limitation Mistake Securities and Exchange Commission 9th Circuit Galleon Murray FTC Costa Rica BrokeandBroker.com Mary Schapiro Selling Away Koval Kenneth Starr Skimming Naskovets Reform Varney Schumer Finra Turnover Hertz Bribe