You probably saw this one on television or read it in the news -- high-profile financial advisor Kenneth Starr was arrested on allegations of wire fraud, fraud by an investment advisor and money laundering. Also, former President of the New York City Council, Andrew Stein, also surrendered to authorities on related charges that he made false statements in an Internal Revenue Service (IRS) filing and made false statements to federal officers concerning a shell company that Starr created and used as a vehicle for his alleged fraud schemes.
Through his firm Starr & Co., Starr managed the assets of, and provided financial planning and investment advice to, high net-worth and celebrity clients. Among other things, Starr paid bills for his clients, assisted them with tax filings, and recommended investments to them. In some cases, Starr assumed total control over his clients' financial lives by collecting their earnings, investing their savings, and paying their bills.
Starr defrauded many of his clients through at least two types of schemes.
- First, on some occasions, Starr solicited money from his clients to invest in what he purported to be sure deals, and then diverted all or some of the investment monies to himself and to risky investments in which he, his wife, and/or his close associates held undisclosed financial interests. Starr’s close associates included, among others, his son; Andrew Stein; a former national official of a major political party; and a partner at a prominent national law firm (referred to in the indictment as "Associate-4").
- Second, where Starr exercised direct control over the personal bank accounts of his clients, Starr used that control to make unauthorized transfers of funds to himself and/or his closest associates. And when Starr’s clients made demands for payments that Starr could not meet, he transferred funds from one client to another client in conduct that was characteristic of a “Ponzi” scheme. Starr engaged in at least $30 million of fraudulent activity against his clients.
To learn the details of Starr's arrest on May 27, 2010, visit:
To learn the details of Starr's 23-count indictment on June 10, 2010, visit: http://www.stopfraud.gov/news/news-06102010.html
On September 10, 2010, the United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York announced that Starr pled guilty and was awaiting sentencing. Below, I have reprinted that Press Release.
FINANCIAL ADVISER KENNETH STARR PLEADS GUILTY
IN MANHATTAN FEDERAL COURT TO MULTIMILLION-DOLLAR FRAUD
PREET BHARARA, the United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York, CYRUS R. VANCE, JR., the District Attorney for New York County, and CHARLES R. PINE, the Special Agent-in-Charge of the New York Field Office of the Internal Revenue Service ("IRS"), Criminal Investigation Division,announced today that financial adviser KENNETH STARR pled guilty in Manhattan federal court to one count each of wire fraud, money laundering, and investment adviser fraud.
According to the previously filed Indictment and Complaint, and statements made at today’s court proceedings before U.S. Magistrate Judge THEODORE H. KATZ:
STARR, through his firm Starr & Co., was in the business of managing the assets of, and providing financial planning and investment advice to, high net-worth and celebrity clients. Among other things, STARR paid bills for his clients,assisted them with tax filings, and recommended investments to them. In some cases, STARR assumed total control over his clients' financial lives by collecting their earnings, investing their savings, and paying their bills.
At today’s plea hearing, STARR admitted, among other things, that between 2009 and 2010, he, on a number of occasions,stole his clients’ money to use for his own purposes. For example, STARR used misappropriated funds to pay a multimillion-dollar legal settlement with a former client, to cover his business’s operating expenses, and to buy himself a multimillion-dollar luxury condominium on Manhattan’s Upper East Side. STARR further admitted that he laundered the stolen money by routing it through an attorney trust account to disguise the true source of the funds. STARR also admitted that he told one client to invest in a company when he knew the investment was simply a loan to a personal friend.
The total loss associated with STARR’s fraud was between $20 million and $50 million.
* * *
STARR, 66, faces a statutory maximum sentence of 45 years, and a recommended Guidelines sentence of 121 to 151 months’ imprisonment. STARR agreed to forfeit the multimillion-dollar Upper East Side condominium he purchased using clients’ money. The Government also reserved the right to seek to forfeit up to $50 million in assets owned or controlled by STARR, and reserved the right to seek up to $50 million in restitution for victims.
STARR’s sentencing is scheduled for December 15, 2010,at 4:30 P.M. before U.S. District Judge SHIRA A. SCHEINDLIN.
Mr. BHARARA praised the investigative work of the New York County District Attorney's Office and the IRS. He also thanked the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC") for its assistance.
Manhattan U.S. Attorney PREET BHARARA stated: "Kenneth Starr's is a tale of fiction and fraud, in which he played the role of legitimate investment adviser to a cast of unsuspecting victims. It is also a cautionary tale for everyone who must rely on financial professionals. Today's guilty plea replaces Starr's trickery with an admission of guilt. We will continue to work steadfastly with our partners at the Manhattan District Attorney's Office, IRS, and SEC to hold accountable financial fraudsters of every stripe."
"This type of serial fraud is a serious crime that threatens the financial well-being of its victims and undermines perceptions of integrity in the financial markets," said New York County District Attorney CYRUS R. VANCE, JR. "Kenneth Starr systematically defrauded his friends, family, and business associates out of tens of millions of dollars through phony deals, repeatedly abusing the trust of those who believed he was an upstanding businessman. I thank our partners in the U.S. Attorney's Office for delivering swift justice for Starr's many victims."
IRS Special-Agent-in-Charge CHARLES R. PINE said: "The guilty plea today reinforces how IRS Criminal Investigation will devote its resources to investigate professionals in financial service areas who violate their positions of trust when they steal clients’ monies and go on spending sprees. We will continue to work with our law enforcement partners and continue to investigate allegations of financial fraud."
Assistant U.S. Attorneys WILLIAM J. HARRINGTON and MICHAEL BOSWORTH, of the Public Corruption Unit of the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York, and Assistant District Attorneys MICHAEL KITSIS and HOPE KORENSTEIN,of the New York County District Attorney's Office, are in charge of the prosecution.
If you believe you were a victim of these crimes,including a victim entitled to restitution, and you wish to provide information to law enforcement and/or receive notice of future developments in the case or additional information, please contact WENDY OLSEN-CLANCY, the Victim Witness Coordinator at the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York, at (866) 874-8900, or Wendy.Olsen@usdoj.gov. For additional information, go to:http://www.usdoj.gov/usao/nys/victimwitness.html on the Internet.
10-282 ### -
To read the above press release, visit: http://www.justice.gov/usao/nys/pressreleases/September10/starrkennethpleapr.pdf
Street Legal: Roads Not Taken
There is a troubling lack of uniformity among regulators
To my eye, one trained through nearly three decades on Wall Street, I fail to appreciate any significant difference between PlanMember and China Yuchai — if anything, China Yuchai seems more directly involved in the software error that resulted in a $12.5 million reported error. As to PlanMember's liability, it seems largely predicated on its third-party vendor's miscue. While I understand that FINRA member firms must exercise reasonable oversight of outsider service providers, FINRA has not convinced me that this member firm's conduct warranted a censure and a $20,000 fine — particularly since a NYSE-listed company seems to have engaged in far worse supervision and merely agreed to a Cease and Desist order.
READ THE COMPLETE ARTICLE BY BILL SINGER AT
Don't Forget to Visit:
Wall Street's Leading Online Community:
The Comprehensive Online Wall Street Regulatory and Legal Website: