An irreverent Wall Street Blog
by Bill Singer

2 Lies to FINRA Add Up to 1 Bar

June 4, 2018

With some folks, it just seems that their luck runs out. After a remarkable run beset with almost losing one's balance, almost falling down, almost getting hit by a falling something or other, almost not getting over an obstacle -- at some point, it ends short of the finish line. No prize. No trophy. Just another also-ran. In today's BrokeAndBroker.com Blog we look back on the career of one stockbroker who almost made it through the Wall Street obstacle course. Perhaps figuring he had several cat lives left, our contestant lied to FINRA and then lied to that regulator again. Not a smart idea the first time. Not a smart idea the second time. 

Case In Point

For the purpose of proposing a settlement of rule violations alleged by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority ("FINRA"), without admitting or denying the findings, prior to a regulatory hearing, and without an adjudication of any issue, Christopher T. Wendel submitted a Letter of Acceptance, Waiver and Consent ("AWC"), which FINRA accepted. In the Matter of Christopher T. Wendel, Respondent (AWC  20170554768 01, June 1, 2018).

The AWC asserts that Wendel entered the industry in 1989 and by September 2014 was registered with FINRA member firm SA Stone Wealth Management Inc. The AWC asserts that "Wendel does not have any formal disciplinary history with the Securities and Exchange Commission, or any self-regulatory organization or any state securities regulator."

Promissory Notes

The AWC alleges that during the relevant period between April and August 2017 while he was associated with SA Stone, Wendel solicited investors to purchase promissory notes in Woodbridge Mortgage Investment Funds, a purported real-estate investment fund. Ultimately, Wendel allegedly sold $343,500 in Woodbridge promissory notes to four individuals for which he purportedly received over $10,000 in commissions. 

The AWC alleges that Wendel did not provide notice to and did not obtain approval from SA Stone prior to participating in what the AWC deemed to be private securities transactions ("PSTs") in violation of FINRA Rules 3280 and 2010. 



False Statements

The AWC alleges that in violation of FINRA Rules 8210 and 2010, that in:
  • January 2018, in response to a Rule 8210 request for information, Wendel provided a signed declaration falsely stating that his participation in the sale of a Woodbridge promissory note occurred after his association with SA Stone had ceased; and
  • March 2018, during his on-the-record testimony ("OTR"), Wendel falsely testified about the alleged post-association note sale. 

Discharge

Online FINRA BrokerCheck records as of June 4, 2018, disclose that S.A. Stone "discharged"  Wendel on September 5, 2017 based upon allegations the he "violated firm policy regarding selling away."

FINRA Sanctions

In accordance with the terms of the AWC, FINRA imposed upon Wendel a Bar in all capacities from association with any FINRA member. 

Bill Singer's Comment

There would seem to be at least two bedrock principles inherent in a registered person's interaction with any industry regulator. One, don't put anything in writing that's a lie. Two, don't say anything on the record that's a lie. A corollary to that second bedrock principle of regulatory interaction is that you should not testify falsely about any falsehood that you previously submitted in written form to a regulator and which also contains falsehoods.  


As to further context against which to form an opinion about Wendel, consider the following:

Settled Complaints

Online BrokerCheck records for Wendel as of June 4, 2018, disclose under the heading "Customer Dispute - Settled" that:
  • former employer WRP Investments  received a FINRA Arbitration Complaint on February 1, 2013, seeking $150,000 in damages based upon allegation that:
CLIENT ALLEGES THAT WENDEL INVESTED A LARGE PORTION OF THE CLIENT'S ASSETS INTO REIT THAT ARE CONSIDERED ILLIQUID AND THAT WENDEL SOLD LOW COST MUTUALFUNDS [sic] TO PURCHASE HIGHER COST MUTUAL FUNDS. CLIENT ALLEGES THAT THESE INVESTMENTS WERE UNSUITABLE FOR HIM BASED ON HIS OBJECTIVES.

WRP settled the matter on April 24, 2014, for $90,000 to which Wendel purportedly contributed the full amount.
  • former employer American Express Financial Advisors received a customer complaint on:
 July 3, 2003, seeking $49,107 in damages based upon allegation that:

THE CLIENT'S ATTORNEY HAS WRITTEN CLAIMING LOSSES DUE TO UNSUITABLE INVESTMENTS

American Express settled the matter on November 7, 2002, for $200,000 to which Wendel purportedly did not contribute. 

April 26, 2000, seeking $130,936.88 in damages based upon allegation that:

THE CLIENT ALLEGED I CONDUCTED UNAUTHORIZED TRADING, SIGNED OR OFFERED TO SIGN THE CLIENT'S SIGNATURE, CONVERT HER STOCK HOLDINGS FROM TYPE "A" TO TYPE "B" MUTUAL FUND SHARES TO HER DISADVANTAGE AND INVESTED IN ANNUITIES AGAINST HER WISHES DURING THE PERIOD OF FEBRUARY AND MARCH, THOUGH NOT IDENTIFIED BY THE CLIENT, DAMAGES ARE ESTIMATED TO EXCEED $5,000.

American Express settled the matter on November 150, 2000, for $130,936.88 to which Wendel purportedly contributed $8,350.00

Pending Complaints

Online BrokerCheck records for Wendel as of June 4, 2018, disclose under the heading "Customer Dispute - Pending" that S.A. Stone received a FINRA Arbitration Complaint on February 20, 2018, seeking $150,000 in damages based upon allegations of unsuitability and failure to supervise.

Closed Without Action Complaints
  • former employer WRP Investments, Inc received a customer complaint dated May 12, 2009, seeking $73,000 in damages based upon allegations:
CLINET'S [sic] SON ALLEGES THAT THE TRANSACTION IN THE LINCOLN NATIONAL VA WAS UNSUITABLE FOR HIS FATHER
  • former employer American Express Financial Advisors denied a customer complaint dated March 28, 2005, seeking $100,000 in damages based upon allegations:
THE CLIENT ALLEGES SHE WAS TOLD HER POLICY'S DEATH BENEFIT WOULD NEVER BE LESS THATN [sic] $250,000.00. SHE IS REQUESTING TO KNOW WHAT HER POLICY WILL BE WORTH UPON HER DEATH

Permalink

Search BrokeAndBroker

Related Topics

Previous Entries

Tag Cloud

Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker FINRA Arbitration AWC SEC BrokeAndBroker.com Expungement Employment Street Sweeper Bill SInger Jobs Wells Fargo Fraud OBA Promissory Note U5 Email U4 Wire Fraud Forbes UBS FBI Merrill Lynch Elderly EFL Statutory Disqualification Morgan Stanley PST ALJ Citigroup Defamation Borrowing Rule 3270 Suitability Ponzi Outside Business Activity OIP BrokerCheck Whistleblower IRS Supervision Wachovia Felony CRD Form U4 Bank Willful Wrongful Termination Mail Fraud DOJ SDNY Supreme Court NAC Insider Trading Expenses BrokerAndBroker Employment Tuesday Form U5 CCO Raymond James Bankruptcy Madoff Ameriprise Pro Se Conversion Discretion Rule 3240 Checks Credit Card OHO WSP NASD Punitive Damages Rule 3040 Private Securities Transaction Forgery IRA RIA Dodd Frank Rule 2010 Rule 8210 JP Morgan Real Estate Indictment Willfulness Outside Business Activities Rule 1122 Discovery Commissions Street Legal Wall Street Guest Blog Exam LPL Settlement Wife Tax NYSE Facebook Estate Rule 2080 Tax Lien Business Expenses ATM Husband Impersonation Power of Attorney 2Cir Antitrust Corrective Action Statement Bar Case In Point Stephen Kohn Schapiro Test Edward Jones SRO Appeal Bank of America Small Firm Wire Rule 3280 Mortgage Schwab Employee Forgivable Loan Margin Trust Annuities Offer of Settlement Tax Liens Rule 2510 Goldman Sachs NSF Conspiracy Trustee Signatures ETF HFT Securities Fraud Spouse Promissory Notes Complaint NASAA ARS Misdemeanor Loan Initial Decision Chase Signature Lien Flash Crash Fidelity Beneficiary Cease And Desist Injunction T&P Away Account Credit Cards Annuity Barclays Huffington Post CFTC BrokeAndBroker VA LOA PCAOB Due Diligence NASDAQ Money Laundering POA DCCir email Deutsche Bank Lehman Brothers Compliance Hacker OTR Liens Unauthorized Discretion Gallagher Registered Rep Magazine Remand MSSB Failure to Supervise RRBDLAW.com Continuing Education Bharara Variable Annuity Bonus Identity Theft Unfair Competition RBC Spouses E*Trade Wedbush Eligibility Rule Solicitation Forex Burris Letter of Authorization Mandatory Arbitration employment FINRA Arbitration Malware Guest Blogger Stockbrokers Annual Compliance Questionnaire Rule 3010 Website JPMorgan Away Accounts Audit Scottrade Stay Social Media Fiduciary Hacking Rule 12805 Registration 2nd Circuit Options Wey Insurance Rule 3050 Rule 12206 Prison LIBOR Second Circuit Net Capital jobs Undisclosed Settlement Solicited arbitration Broker Protocol FOREX 10Cir Trading Platform Bureau of Prisons Will Retirement Brummer BOP Rule 4530 Customer Complaint TRO RRBDlaw.com Telephone Internet IC3 FINOP Time And Price BrokeAndBroker Bill Singer brokeandbroker Reg SP Plea Private Placement Private Securities Transactions Great Recession Rule 4511 Newman Judgments Unsolicited DOL Disclosure MetLife Spoofing Rule 2111 OWB Sanctions Cheating Reimbursement Divorce China Obstruction of Justice Unauthorized Trading Auction Rate Securities Check Kiting Self Regulation Hedge Fund Apple Motion to Dismiss Willfully BrokeandBroker NYAG Dissent Confidential Information RMBS REIT ADA Knight Rakoff Piwowar Protocol Examination Explained Decision Wire Transfer Sanction Guidelines Shah Gilani Class Action MF Global Due Process Executor Commission Affinity Fraud Confidential Aleynikov Morgan Keegan Disgorgement bill singer Reg D Lehman Woody Allen 9Cir Passcode Phishing Rule 2150 Botkin PNC Khuzami Affiliate Ketchum Vacatur Medicare Bandimere Gold Debit Card Regulation SP EIA SAC Crowdfunding Retaliation Board IPO Waiver Variable Annuities Hurry PN Article V Arbitraiton Banc of America Unsuitability OSHA Wine Joshua Brown Customer High Frequency Trading Postponement Deceased Stifel Charge Raiding Discrimination Rule 2081 Sexist Rosenthal Recruiting Pennystock Hearing Jurisdiction Small Firm Governor Eligibility Loans Statute of Limitations Whistleblowing Laptop Compensation Bear Stearns Confirm Poteroba Side Bar Marijuana Bid Rigging Ride the Thunder Mutual Fund Vault Bank Fraud Vietnam Private Placements NPR Marine Corps Indemnification Self Regulatory Organization Marines Rule 12200 Online Corruption Customer Information Lawyer Testimony Morgan Stanley Smith Barney Charles Schwab Rule 3030 Stifel Nicolaus Sexism Termination MC-400 Consent Order ING 401k AML Teleconference Pennystocks Commodities Fraud OIG Morgan Stanely WSPs CEO Testing White Appointments Clause Day Trading ACQ Fees Yesenia Guitron Rule 13805 Sales Assistant Deferred Compensation Penson Unjust Enrichment Government Accountability Project Embezzlement Disability Series 7 Guitron Personal Expenses Chief Compliance Officer USERRA Information 6th Circuit Statement of Corrective Action Charity Stanford Zipper Employment Agreement Oppenheimer Johnny Burris JOBS Act Check McDuff Parking Suspension Dakota Securities HSBC Kon Unregistered Casino Lucia Reg S-P Conflict Marketplace Corzine Whitman CE Failure To Supervise Aguilar Finder\'s Fee Bloomberg Widow Smith Barney Feigenbaum Department of Justice Fifth Amendment Administrative Remedies Inside Information Written Supervisory Procedures Inmate Investment Adviser Taft Correctional Institution Sexual Harassment 4Cir Elles Scottsdale Severance Layering IAR Christian Stanley Chase Investment Services BD Outside Account 40 Act Emails Guest Bloggers Counterclaim Rule 2210 Form ADV Arrest Frumento Probate Reverse Life Insurance Elder Abuse TD Ameritrade FINRA AWC Schneiderman Red Flags Thain Leveraged ETF Female Inability to Pay Hilton Weiner Investor Alert OWWP Verbal Discretion BrokerAndBroker.com OCIE Third Party Vendor Accounting Restaurant Commodities Rule 9216 Non-Solicitation CNBC Churning Rule 3110 Stipulated Award Margin Call Hospital Client Information Negligence Stockbroker Mutual Funds FCI RRBDlaw 401(k) Bonds Rule 1031 Rule 2370 TheBlot Florida Argentina Scholander Imposter Backstage Wall Street Broke And Broker David Sobel Judgment Research CGMI Moon SP expungement FCI Beaumont BATS Outside Accounts WaMu Netschi Moore Fine ACH 11th Circuit Unauthorized Practice of Law Dementia Tax Fraud Tortious Interference Trade Secrets CPA Circuit Court Oral Discretion Do Not Call Dell FNMA TSSB Lincoln Financial Credit Suisse Timban Equity Indexed Annuities Sharemaster Fowler TIC FOCUS Chiasson Medical Condition Walter Subway Diabetes Compromise Dow Sexual Discrimination Reverse Merger Scam Schumer Proctor Rules of Practice In House Counsel Joint Account Mother Branch Manager Fourth Amendment iPhone false statements Books and Records Obstruction Bartko Dinner EDNY God FCPA Motion Wells Fargo Advisors Cannabis Immunity Personal Information NRSRO 8210 CDO Promoter SunTrust Sharing Agreement Relevant Supervisor FNI Media Gabelli Varney Municipal Advisor Collateral Bar Retroactive Bar NYG Capital Retroactive Falsification Costa Rica Motion To Dismiss Rule 13200 Lek Liquidation S&P US Airways FMLA Salman Hugh Hewitt Elder Fraud Settling Away Euro JPM Aegis Frumento FINRA Small Firm Prime Bank Undertaking GAP Eric Stein Johnson Commissioner Stein FTC Star Wars Undercover AWC. FINRA Fiduciary Duty Boyland Cellphone Subpoena Short Sale Resignation Escrow Standing Expense Stephen A. Kohn Lewis Carroll BitTorrent Manifest Disregard PIABA Executrix Attorneys Fees Securities and Exchange Commission NML Impersonator FINRA Board Nasdaq Sex 1Cir Wages Kennedy Board of Governors LLC Constructive Discharge Mistake 9th Circuit Silver Theft Privilege Naskovets Reason for Termination Skimming Apartment Google Customer Files Selling Away Lee Koval Electronic Communications Excel Murray BBVA Nationwide Altered Records Kenneth Starr Tipper Stop Loss SEC Rules of Practice Test Center Tippee Galleon Turbeville Obamacare Fee Brokeandbroker.com Flash Drive Disparate Treatment Withdrawals Tennis Court Unsuitable Enforcement Retired Woman With Cane Fines NFA Concentration Springsteen McCartney CRS RRBDLAW Regulation Books And Records Fiero Customers BrokeAndBroke Money Market TOD Password Reform Initials Pruco Cybercrime Congress Mattera Goble FDA Compliance Questionnaire PAQ Taxes BrokeandBroker.com Mary Schapiro David Lerner Criminal House Financial Services Data Laser Trainee Fee DWI Broy Leveraged ETFs Evidence Quasi Governmental Over Concentration SIPC Rule 9552 Solomon Rule 420 Advisor Placement Group AXA Preet Bharara AIG Blank Forms Non Solicitation Oilpro Counterfeit Statutory Disqualification Committee VIX VXX signature Cherry Picking Office of Special Counsel Kent 1099 Permanent Bar Chevron Hertz Outside Counsel Death Bank Guarantee Regulation S-P Bribe Reuters Mary Jo White Spam Spoliation Compliance Officer Texas State Securities Board Grievance Martin 17a-5 Stock Promotion Bill Singer BrokeAndBroker Annual Audit Trader Merger SD Rule 4513 Credit Repair Summary Judgment Membership Continuance Public Interest Tran Practice Sale Motion to Vacate Martoma Trading Texting Countrywide Payroll Federal Reserve Anderson Kiting Checking Wanger Non-Prosecution Agreement Jon Corzine Exhaustion Doctrine Ethics Lawyers Attorneys\' Fees Merrill Currency Collateral Pacifico Disciplinary History Pension