SEC Sanctions Guggenheim Securities For Anti-Whistleblower Confidentiality Agreement

June 28, 2021

A decade ago, the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act launched Wall Street's federal whistleblower program. A keystone of the Act was that it prohibited efforts to impede communications by tipsters to the SEC. Confidentiality agreements that enabled employers to threaten reprisals against employees who contacted the SEC were deemed a prohibited practice. Some companies got the message. Others not quite so. 

Case In Point

Without admitting or denying the SEC's findings, Respondent Guggenheim Securities, LLC ("GS") submitted an Offer of Settlement whereby the company consented to the entry of an Order Instituting Proceedings and Imposing Sanctions and Order ("OIP").  In the Matter of Guggenheim Securities, LLC, Respondent (SEC Order Instituting Administrative and Cease-And-Desist Proceedings and Imposing Remedial Sanctions and Order; '34 Act Rel. No.92237; Admin. Proc. File No. 3-20370 / June 23, 2021)

The OIP asserts that GS has been a registered broker-dealer since 1997 with over 600 registered representatives at 16 branches. 

The GS Manual

During the relevant period from about April 15, 2016 to July 2020, GS transmitted to its employees (upon their hire and thereafter on an annual basis) a GS Core Compliance Manual (the "GS Manual"), which required their signed acknowledgement of having read the contents and their required compliance with the stated policies. In part, under "Communications with Regulators"  the GS Manual stated:

Employees are also strictly prohibited from initiating contact with any Regulator without prior approval from the Legal or Compliance Department. This prohibition applies to any subject matter that might be discussed with a Regulator, including an individual's registration status with FINRA. Any employee that violates this policy may be subject to disciplinary action by the Firm.

Further, the GS Manual's "Introduction" provides in part that:

There may be circumstances in which a GS policy or procedure may be more (or less) restrictive than a GC policy or procedure. In all such circumstances, GS personnel should follow the more restrictive of the policies or procedures, absent explicit direction to the contrary. 

Code of Conduct

GS employees were required to comply with the "Code of Conduct" promulgated by what the OIP characterizes as the Respondent's "majority indirect owner is Guggenheim Capital, LLC . . ." During the relevant period,  the Code of Conduct asserted under "Public Statements" that it:

should not be interpreted to restrict or interfere with any employee's rights, free speech, or any whistleblower protections under applicable laws, regulations and requirements.

Further, in July 2016, the Code of Conduct was amended under "Prompt and Confidential Reporting of Illegal or Unethical Conduct" to disclose that:

Nothing in this policy or any other Company policy or agreement is intended to prohibit you (with or without prior notice to the Company) from reporting to or participating in an investigation with a government agency or authority about a possible violation of law, or from making other disclosures protected by applicable whistleblower statutes.

Annual Training Materials

In 2018/2019, GS's annual compliance training included materials under a "Communication with Regulator" that set out this bullet-point:

Employees are prohibited from initiating contact with any regulator without prior approval from Legal or Compliance, including conversation[s] regarding an individual's registration status with FINRA.

Dodd-Frank Rule

Effective August 12, 2011, Rule 12G-17 as promulgated under the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act provides in part that: 

(a) No person may take any action to impede an individual from communicating directly with the Commission staff about a possible securities law violation, including enforcing, or threatening to enforce, a confidentiality agreement . . . with respect to such communications.

SEC Sanctions

The OIP asserts that GS's above-described conduct constituted the willful violation of Rule 21F-17, and in accordance with the Offer of Settlement, the SEC imposed upon GS a Censure and a $208,912 civil money penalty; and the firm was ordered to cease and desist from further violations of the cited Rule.

In imposing sanctions, the OIP asserts that the  SEC considered the following:

13. After it was contacted by the Commission staff in this matter, GS revised the GS Manual by removing the language described in paragraph 5 above and adding the following language affirmatively advising employees of their right to contact regulators with concerns about potential legal or regulatory violations: 

nothing in [the GS Manual] prohibits or restricts any person in any way from reporting possible violations of law or regulation to any governmental agency or entity, or otherwise prevent anyone from participating, assisting, or testifying in any proceeding or investigation by any such agency or entity or from making other disclosures that are protected and/or permitted under law or regulation. 

14. The revised GS Manual further notes that: 

[n]othing in this Manual, any agreement between GS and its employees, or any GS policy or program requires a person to obtain prior authorization from GS to make any such reports or disclosures to any governmental agency or entity or to notify GS that an individual intends to make or has made such reports or disclosures. 

GS communicated the revisions to its employees through a compliance alert, which linked to the revised GS Manual.

Bill Singer's Comment

The SEC showed a lot of leniency in this settlement, and, frankly, I'm not sure that it was warranted. The anti-whistleblower written policy was clearly drafted and implemented by Guggenheim and, notably, the policy was not revised on Guggenheim's own volition but, as Paragraph 13 notes, after the SEC had contacted the company. 

SEC Sanctions Guggenheim Securities For Anti-Whistleblower Confidentiality Agreement ( Blog)

Joseph Meli Sentenced To 37 Months In Prison For Participating In Broadway Ticket Resale Investment Fraud Scheme (DOJ Release)

U.S. Attorney Announces Extradition And Guilty Plea Of Israeli Securities Trader For Participating In A Global Insider Trading Ring / Insider Trading Charges Are Also Unsealed Against a Second Israeli Trader for Participating in the Same Multimillion-Dollar Scheme (DOJ Release)

SEC Charges Private Fund Manager, Consumer Credit Company, and Three Individuals with Fraudulently Raising Over $73 Million from Investors (SEC Release)

SEC Charges Amec Foster Wheeler Limited With FCPA Violations Related To Brazilian Bribery Scheme (SEC Release)

FINRA Censures and Fines Merrill Lynch Over UIT Supervision
In the Matter of Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith Incorporated, Respondent (FINRA AWC)

FINRA Fines and Suspends Rep for Unsuitable UIT Short-Term Trading
In the Matter of Kelly Wayne Feehrer, Respondent (FINRA AWC)

FINRA Censures and Fines Sidoti & Company, LLC Over Research Reports
In the Matter of Sidoti & Company, LLC, Respondent (FINRA AWC)