Bill Singer Calls for Boycott of 2023 FINRA Elections

June 16, 2023

FINRA's Board of Governors is a lackluster amalgamation that is tone deaf to the legitimate needs of its smaller members and resistant to implementing the necessary reforms to protect the investing public and the industry's financial professionals. FINRA's Small Firm members represent some 90% of the membership but are gerrymandered down to about 13% of the Board Governors. Since the Small Firm Members are of no apparent consequence, I urge the Small Firm community to boycott all 2023 FINRA elections. Further, until such time as FINRA demonstrates a sincere commitment to reform, I urge all FINRA member firms to instruct their Executive Representative to not cast a vote for any candidate in any 2023 FINRA election by way of a boycott. 

In January 2021, the FINRA Board of Governors appointed Goldman Sachs' General Counsel to fill the Floor Member Governor's seat. There was no election. The Governor was hand picked, and her appointment was approved by the full Board. By way of context, on September 10, 2010, plaintiffs had filed a Complaint asserting claims for gender discrimination in pay, performance evaluation, and promotion under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and the New York City Human Rights Law. On March 30, 2018, the case was certified as a class action; and trial was set to begin on June 7, 2023.The Governors who voted to approve the nomination of Goldman Sachs' General Counsel knew or should have known about the troubling allegations set out in the pending 2010 Class Action against Goldman Sachs. 

In 2021, no FINRA Governor reportedly challenged the appointment of Goldman Sachs' General Counsel to the Board of Governors of Wall Street's leading self-regulatory-organization. In 2022, as the shocking allegations mounted, no FINRA Governor reportedly requested the resignation of Goldman Sachs' General Counsel. Even in 2023, amid a flood of allegations and evidence, FINRA's Board of Governors said nothing. Goldman Sachs settled the Class Action gender discrimination charges by 2,800 female associates and vice presidents at a cost of $215 million. “Goldman Sachs to pay $215 mln to settle gender discrimination lawsuit” (Reuters / May 9, 2023)

The appointment of Goldman Sachs' General Counsel by FINRA's Board placed the self-regulatory-organization in an unflattering light of hypocrisy given its efforts to depict itself as a bastion of inclusion and diversity: "FINRA Creates Industry Diversity Advisory Committee / New Committee Highlights FINRA’s Commitment to Improving DEI in the Securities Industry" (FINRA Release / November 9, 2022) Notwithstanding FINRA's belated efforts to acknowledge d
iscrimination and harassment in the industry, those were not issues that had been hidden from Wall Street's regulators. As I noted many years ago in "Why Is The NYSE And NASD Soft On Racism And Sexism?" ( Blog / March 9, 2006)

Please, show me the cases those regulators brought in the past 50 years in which member firms were charged with permitting racial or sexual discrimination/harassment. And what's the message? The regulators unwittingly encourage intolerant behavior by not deeming these practices to be conduct that offends basic notions of "high principles" and "honor." Do the SROs see such conduct as nothing more than an indiscretion? 
. . .

I hear these heart-rending stories virtually every day when I am contacted by potential clients. If this cancer is tolerated by Wall Street's regulators, how will we ever destroy it? If the NYSE and NASD see fit to bar folks from the brokerage industry because they have had felony convictions for drunk driving, then it's high time we roll out the same artillery to combat illegal discrimination.

Placing FINRA in the unflattering light of hypocrisy and raising questions as to the regulator's complicity, are the very words of FINRA's bedrock regulatory rule:


A member, in the conduct of its business, shall observe high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

Despite decades of discrimination and harassment at many of its member firms, FINRA failed to file charges . . . failed to take action. If sexism and racism are not among the most classic examples of commercial dishonor, what is? If sexism and racism are not the hallmarks of injustice and inequity, what is? Presented with this squalor on Wall Street, no one on FINRA's Board ever spoke up; and even today, no one is speaking out. Instead of action we get press releases, outside consultants, white papers, and blue-ribbon panels. 

Gender/racial discrimination is not a dirty, little secret on Wall Street. It's long been out there in the open. The message from those in power is to look the other way, keep quiet, and don't rock the boat. Now, in 2023, when we are confronted with the reality of Goldman Sachs' $215 million settlement, it is absurd to pretend that nothing was ever amiss. And yet, despite all of that, those who know better, those who should speak up and speak out, still shrink from their ethical and moral obligations. FINRA's Board is silent. Wall Street's regulators are silent. Wall Street's trade groups are silent. It is all deafening.

There is no commercial honor, no justice, no equity when it comes to the regulation of Wall Street. The industry is a cesspool that many smell but few admit to seeing. There are none so blind as those who will not see. The most deluded people are those who choose to ignore what they already know.

Also see: 

SEC Sends FINRA Expungement Back to the Future ( Blog)

BREAKING NEWS: SCOTUS Says Government May Dismiss a False Claims Act / Qui Tam Actions
United States, ex rel. Jesse Polansky, M.D., M.P.H., Petitioner, v. Executive Health Resources, Inc., et al. (Opinion, Supreme Court of the United States, No. 21-1052, 599 U.S. __ (2023))

SCOTUS Says No Double Jeopardy Attaches When Defendant Found Guilty by Jury in Wrong Jurisdiction -- Allows Retrial
Timothy J. Smith, Petitioner, v. United States (SCOTUS Opinion)

Attorney General James Recovers $1.7 Million from Cryptocurrency Platform for Operating Illegally / CoinEx Required to Stop Operating in the U.S., Pay Penalties, and Refund New York Investors (NYAG Release)

NYS Court of Appeals Says Investment Bank Could Be Liable for Negligent Supervision and Employee Retention 
The Moore Charitable Foundation, et al., Appellants, v. PJT Partners, Inc., et al., Defendant (Opinion, State of New York Court of Appeals, No. 52)

Federal Court Denies Alpine's Emergency Motion for a Preliminary Injunction or Temporary Restraining Order against FINRA
Scottsdale Capital Advisors Corporation And Alpine Securities Corporation, Plaintiffs, v. Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc., Defendant - and - United States Of America, Intervenor Defendants (Opinion, United States District Court for the District of Columbia, 23-CV-1506)


Orange County Lawyer Agrees to Plead Guilty to Multimillion-Dollar Fraud of Victims Who Believed They Were Funding Loan Program (DOJ Release)

St. Petersburg Man Who Orchestrated Multimillion Dollar Fraud Scheme While On Supervised Release Sent Back To Prison For Theft Of Government Property And Money Laundering (DOJ Release)


SEC Charges Microcap Company, Its CEO, and Former Consultant with Fraud and Registration Violations (SEC Release)

SEC Charges PIMCO for Disclosure and Policies and Procedures Failures (SEC Release)

SEC Affirms Denial of FINRA Arbitration Forum for Expungement
In the Matter of the Application of Alton Theodore Davis, Jr. For Review of Action Taken by FINRA 

SEC Charges Ohio Investment Adviser with Misappropriating Over $1.3 Million from a Retail Investor (SEC Release)

SEC Charges Two Individuals in Connection with Fraudulent Scheme to IIIegally Sell Stock to the Public (SEC Release)

SEC Charges Pennsylvania Man in $30 Million Offering Fraud (SEC Release)

SEC Charges Investment Adviser and Principal in Abusive Naked Short Selling Scheme (SEC Release)

SEC Unveils New Public Service Campaign Encouraging Older Investors to Never Stop Learning (SEC Release)

SEC Denies Whistleblower Award to Two Claimants 
Order Determining Whistleblower Award Claim 


Federal Court Orders Wisconsin Resident and Her Companies to Pay More than $24 Million for Forex Fraud Targeting Local Hmong Community (CFTC Release)


FINRA Fines and Suspends Rep for Discretionary Trades in Customers' Accounts
In the Matter of  Michelle Wu, Respondent (FINRA AWC)

FINRA Fines and Suspends Rep for Changing Rep Code
In the Matter of Richard F. Spettell, Respondent (FINRA AWC)

FINRA Fines and Suspends Rep for Willful Failure to Timely Disclose Felony Charge
In the Matter of Thomas Vernor, Respondent (FINRA AWC)

FINRA Fines and Suspends Rep for Reimbursement of Personal Expenses
In the Matter of Colin Healy, Respondent (FINRA AWC)

FINRA Fines and Suspends Rep for  Accepting Monetary Gifts from Senior Customers
In the Matter of Sharom Hayut, Respondent (FINRA AWC)

The FINRA Examination Team: The Ins and Outs of FINRA’s Annual Program (FINRA Podcast)